Maine Coon Breeder Dumps Kitten At Animal Shelter

By Elisa Black-Taylor

While I was doing a little social “petworking” (a new word for the modern age) the other night, I came across the story of a Maine Coon cat that I knew I had to share with the readers here. It’s about a Maine Coon breeder who dumped a pedigree Maine Coon kitten at the local shelter because she didn’t “like his markings.”

I’m not talking about backyard breeders or people who throw two cats together to see what kind of kittens come out of the mating. I’m talking about an apparently well known and respected breeder whose excuse, besides the markings, was she “didn’t want the kitten associated with her cattery.” That tells me this is either a renowned breeder or just thinks she is.

The story of how the cat got a home is a sweet one. A lady had come into the animal shelter late in the day and was looking at the “marked” kitten. The shelter manager came over to her and told her it was the Maine Coon’s last day and went on to explain how the Maine Coon breeder had just dumped off this kitten. Of course, this kind-hearted woman adopted the kitten on the spot.

Readers, I looked at the picture of this pedigree Maine Coon, who is now a couple of years old. I wish I’d saved it to my computer to share with all of you. There was nothing physically unappealing about this cat!

I believe this particular breeder is not only full of herself, she shouldn’t be allowed to call herself a professional breeder. Why not give the kitten to a family friend? Oh wait, the friend might tell someone the kitten came from this well respected cattery.

As with any other business, I imagine catteries have to have certain standards to maintain high rankings in the cat world. But to dump a kitten at the shelter is beyond belief. Not only did she abandon this sweet little kitten, this kitten took the space of another cat who needed to find a home.

I went online and tried to find out a little about breeding cats. I’m far from an expert and hope the readers here can help. First of all, have any of you ever heard of a situation like this? I once worked with a German Shepherd breeder (with genuine German dogs) who would only adopt out so many puppies from one litter. Is this the way it works with cats? Do only the first 4-5 kittens go up for sale or does the breeder try to sell as many as the queen gives birth to. What happens to the kittens who don’t measure up to standards?

I looked into complaints on breeders and found most of them were from selling sick kittens or from inaccurate information on pedigree. I found nothing on how many kittens per litter was preferable or what type of markings would make a cattery look bad.

I did learn that legitimate cat breeders enjoy showing their cats, and unless it’s a new breed, most do show their cats. It’s a red flag to buy from a breeder who doesn’t show. I also read that reputable breeders stick together.

I wonder what a top notch Maine Coon breeder would think of a breeder who does a shelter turn in based on markings. Or does this happen a lot?

This isn’t a topic I can contact a breeder about and just asked outright if the breeder would ever consider dumping a kitten at an animal shelter because of poor markings. What does this say about a breeder who does this?

I find myself wondering how often this is done. The shelter employee who told the history of this particular abandoned kitten knew the breeder. Does this mean this wasn’t the first time this happened? The kitten was on it’s “last day” at the shelter before euthanasia. So the breeder must have known the risk of euthanasia and did it anyway. I wonder whether the shelter manager tells the breeder the kittens she has left in the past (if applicable) all found homes, giving her an excuse to dump more off in the future.

I’m sorry to say this shows the cold-hearted nature of some people who make themselves out to be cat lovers.

I realize most of us at this website stand up more for the moggies and ferals of the world because there are simply too many of them. Breeders serve a purpose to improve on their favorite pedigree. The majority do it with pride and good intent.

Have any of the readers heard of anything this low-down being done? I’m just curious. To those of you who know more about breeding, is there a limit to how many kittens from one litter will be sold? I’m still wondering what imperfection made the Maine Coon breeder turn in a kitten.

Comments anyone?

Elisa

Facebook Comments

Comments

Maine Coon Breeder Dumps Kitten At Animal Shelter — 42 Comments

  1. Pet Quality

    I find this post interesting and upsetting. A lot of cats created by cat breeders are not going to be up to the mark, the standard set by the cat association or the breeder. These are called “pet quality” as far as I am aware. Or some other terminology that means the same thing. These cats are not for showing or breeding from but are sold at a discount price to someone.

    That is what is meant to happen. However, some breeders don’t seem to have the ethics nor the morality to discharge their obligations towards the cats they create.

    Killing Kittens

    While in the USA visiting Helmi Flick and going to a cat show I was told of one breeder who killed (by drowning?) newborns or very young kittens that were not good enough. She justified it by saying that it wasn’t really killing cats because they were so young. Extraordinary story.

    It has always concerned me what happens to poor quality purebred cats. Now we know what one breeder does. A cat breeder has an obligation towards the cats she creates for the lifetime of the cats in a strict sense. There are already too many unwanted cats. To add to that so carelessly is unforgivable and cruel.

  2. I recall seeing ads for pet quality kittens being offered by a breeder. It seems this breeder just took the easy way out. Perhaps we should feel fortunate she didn’t kill the kitten.

  3. What an idiot. Wow. The breeder I the most extensive knowledge about worked in a network of breeders and was more about keeping the breeding pool as large as possible, as apposed to looks. She adopted all the other kittens that didn’t go to other breeders out. She also adopted out some of her studs and queens after they were retired to good homes.

    Mythicbelles Persians is a more well known breeder I follow. She adopts out all her kittens and likes to follow up on them as the years go by as adopters are willing. You can see tons of videos and pix of her cats all over Youtube and Facebook. She obviously loves everyone of those little guys and gals.

    This woman is strange, to be certain. There is something not right about the whole thing. What, other than her story, could of been the motive for her to do this. She certainly didn’t care for the money she was gonna be out — not that I approve of that type of breeder in the least. Nor did she love the kitten. I wonder if it was a cover story. Perhaps she under the impression the kitten had medical issues. Maybe it was stolen? I just can’t believe a breeder that was so worried about appearance would draw attention to herself. I think she was hiding something. I really do. Glad the cat is alive and well. Great article. Thanks

  4. Just read a blog where the woman posted pix from the above unnamed Maine Coon breeder (they are out of business). This woman posted pix from their website that had to be lifted out with some kind of tool. They use .gif files with a clear layer on top so you can’t copy their photos. Not only did she pilfer them, she didn’t even bother to mention the source. I’m waiting to hear back from her. She may not of been the one to steal them. Still, Maine Coon skulduggery everywhere. Meowzers!

    • Try using PhotoScape free photo software. It has a screenshot feature that works well. Bet it would lift them. I use it to copy receipts to post as I don’t have a printer.

      I’m still trying to find the picture of the cat. I’ve been making Sealy as many cat friends as possible to promote the danger of car fan blades. I’ve sent out hundreds of friend requests and until she accepts I won’t know who the cat was. If I find it I’ll post the link.

  5. I honestly believe this particular breeder might have just been unable to kill the kitten him/herself. I’m sure many of them just do it themselves. Its a conflict of interest. You can’t have a situation where winning awards is based on the quality of a living thing you are showing. That living being simply then becomes an object to be valued in terms of ones own personal success – and is no longer treated as a living being. It would be ok if they were sculptures, but they are infact nothing to do with the person who’s success depends on them. Its a total conflict of interest and the cats really lose out badly on this particular flawed setup. It should be illegal to show the cats you sell – or something like that. Or it should just not be competitive at all. I agree with Elizabeth. The flaw is with the person and not the cat and this counts for all circumstances. The cat fancy is nothing short of a little frightening. They whole system of it, along with the rewards and success just can’t work right because we know that humans are flawed actually, especially when it comes to money and success. This once again proves that in modern culture, success often goes to those who are willing to be bad, do wrong, or who simply have no shame and no awareness and who scramble to the top of the stupid ladder. Success is a very personal thing in my opinion. I hope the winners of the money and recognition live sorry pitiful lives in their personal time. Thats all I can say.

  6. That is most certainly not the typical procedure for an apparent reputable breeder. But, these days, the term “reputable breeder” cannot be trusted. I have seen reputable breeders who turn out to be puppy farmers, or are selling puppies and kittens who have tested positive to devastating hereditary conditions.

    My cat does not meet show standards. He was born with a kink in his tail. He wasn’t taken to a shelter, he wasn’t euthanised at a vet, he was adopted out into a pet home. With someone who had no interest in showing or breeding him. This is what real, genuine, reputable breeders do. But other breeders don’t want to put the effort into finding homes for their ‘dodgy’ kittens, and they don’t want to admit to having bred these kittens. The Maine Coon’s unsatisfactory markings doesn’t make it any less a Maine Coon, nor does Chilli’s tail kink make him any less an Abyssinian, so I really don’t understand this very disturbing logic.

    However, any “breeder”, reputable or not, should probably not be trusted to begin with. Anyone who produces more kittens, while others are being killed at disturbingly high numbers in shelters, cannot possibly actually care for cats…

  7. Pingback: Siamese Cat Picture Gallery | Pictures of Cats

  8. This subject disturbs me greatly. Volunteering at our no-kill shelter, you would be amazed at how many pedigree cats (and dogs) are dumped. The excuses are palpable…no time, can’t afford to show, moving – the list is endless! Thanks Elisa for bringing this terrible practice to light.

      • Agreed Michael – interesting point nonetheless. Sadly the public shelter system in the US might in some cases be worse than the unfamiliar outdoors. Both are deplorable in most cases. Of course there is a tiny bit of success in there somewhere but to drop your cat off at a public shelter honestly hoping it won’t be killed is nothing short of keeping hope alive – perhaps simply to enable the person to do it in the first place. You wouldn’t have dropped a Jewish child off at a concentration camp now would you – same thing.

  9. I am reserving my comment to a subject that hasn’t been addressed. Those of us who work in the animal welfare/sheltering world are distressed by the word “dumped” in reference to a humane animal shelter. Dumped is when whole litters of kittens or single adult cats are taken to an unfamiliar area and left to fend for themselves or be taken in by good Samaritans. A shelter is a facility intended to–that’s right–provide shelter to an unwanted animal and offer at least the possibility of a new home. Yes, yes, there are all kinds of shelters. The starkest difference these days are those that are paid for out of public monies and MUST take all and therefore must and will euthanize for space; and those that are private and hand can say “no,” (so called limited access shelters). This Maine Coon breeder chose a municipal shelter, which is the part of the story that disturbs me the most, but I suspect she knew a purebred kitten would be one of the lucky ones.

    • You make a good point that shelters do rehome cats. On that basis the word “dumped” is not suitable. But in the context of the story – a Maine Coon purebred cat abandoned or relinquished to a publicly funded shelter, where there is probably a high chance of euthanasia, I think the word is appropriate.

      • I only use the word dumped to show the lack of concern by the person who left the cat. It means she didn’t try to resolve the situation any other way. I love working with the shelter I pulled from. Most shelter workers I’ve met are caring people who are genuinely concerned in rehoming cats.

  10. I think cat breeders create an environment where the worst of human nature can flourish – the tendency to think we own the world and can do as we please in it. One aspect of owning everything is to treat animals as secondary creatures to do as we please with. It is human arrogance and ignorance expressed in animal cruelty.

  11. Re: Michael’s question, our no-kill shelter (10 miles south of Boston) is small-approx. 35-40 cats & 10-12 dogs max. Of 100 cats, the average is around 25 pedigreed & of 50 dogs, the average is around 10 pedigreed (some with papers). For exotic cats (Serval), we contact an appropriate breed rescue group to give the cat (or dog) optimum opportunity of appropriate care/placement.

    Re: Marion Lane’s comment, while I understand bristling at using “dumped,” unfortunately, it is appropriate in this context. New England weather, especially in winter, is very unpredictable. I’d hate to tell you how many times over the past 3.5 years of volunteering the animals we’ve found: dogs tethered in the frigid cold to the outside doorknob or dumped in the outside fenced-in area. On 3 occasions, I’ve found KITTENS in cardboard boxes taped up with air holes in the side and/or cat carriers left OUTSIDE the shelter door while we were closed. So far, we haven’t lost any, but even with giant signs on the door saying it’s ILLEGAL, it’s still done. So sad.

  12. The sad but true fact of “PROFESSIONAL PET BREEDERS”, cats, dogs or horses.Only the best of the type are retained, some good breeders giving away the discards for free while others might euthanize them.Remember, maintenance of a breeders pet livestock is expensive if unsold or of inferior quality to the characteristics of the breed.

    • Absolutely Rudolph. You have hit the nail on the head. Breeding is a business and I don’t know how you mix efficient business and high level animal welfare. I don’t think the two are compatible.

  13. Marion, just the past month, we had 2 mother cats found with un-weaned litters ‘dumped’ outside our shelter – 1 in a cardboard box and 1 in a cat carrier. It’s despicable. On the humane side, we had a Good Samaritan bring us a newborn kit she found near some bushes. The Good Sam waited over an hour hoping the momma cat would show up, but when she didn’t, the lady retrieved the kit. We had to force-feed formula with a syringe – the poor baby’s eyes weren’t even open yet. Thankfully, a foster had a lactating cat & she accepted little “Figaro” as part of her litter. In this scenario, the ‘dumped’ term does not apply.

  14. You wouldn’t believe the number of cats we rescued from the shelter turned in as “strays” yet smelled of laundry detergent and clean linen. Those cats had been living inside as someone’s pets and the people just say they’re strays because there’s a $35-40 charge for a cat owner to willingly turn in a pet to the shelter. They’ve been lined up out the door with turn ins late in the day when we would go pull a rescue.

      • Agreed, Michael. On the plus side; however, when turned in to a humane shelter, at least these little ones have a chance at life. Last spring, I attended a conference in Connecticut sponsored by the Humane Society and found this abandonment practice is not unique. The only upside is that,through careful screening, cats are placed in loving homes. Being non-profit, every penny counts so the pedigreed cats bring higher prices in some shelters. Ours hold prices at $125/adult and $150/kitten. Placing pedigreed cats sometimes means additional donations to the shelter from those savvy enough to know what they have. We’ve been fortunate to also have some of our cats (and dogs) becoming famous – cats in print/movies/showcase; dogs becoming K9 drug/therapy/gun-sniffing heroes.

        As for the abandoned mommas/litters, they’ve all been placed except for Figaro as he’s still too young and one momma cat who’s app is pending.

        For this horrendous breeder to ditch a Maine Coon kitten because it wasn’t perfect is tantamount to signing this poor one’s death warrant. Thankfully, it was placed. How many others haven’t been as fortunate?

        • I agree that many shelters do great work. We agree to that this breeder was reckless as to whether the cat she created was killed or not. And I am sure there are other breeders (not many I hope) who do similar things.

          If you questioned her she would probably find some sort of self-deceiving justification such as vets make when justifying declawing (“saving lives”).

  15. The shelter I rescued from isn’t no kill. They do manage to place a good many cats between networking and adoption events. But at least 20-30% are euthanized for lack of room. They’ve had as many as 100 cats turned in in one day. Here’s the page of those euthanized this year. https://www.facebook.com/media/set/?set=a.197323487012588.49588.194011810677089&type=3. There just aren’t enough homes or the cats become sick or they get in 20 litters in one day. I know the lady who tries to find homes for all of the cats. She even has an email list she sends daily to rescues. Once an email is sent to her stating the cat has a rescue or foster going to pull it, then it’s considered safe until pickup arrangements can be made. This is where every rescue we have came from.

    • I’m sure you’ll agree Elisa that some cats that come into shelters may have been on the fringe of health, but due to being exposed to so many cats with their weak immune system, it may lead to them getting sick and, ultimately, killed. You’ve done extraordinary work in this area, but even you can only do so much.

      Last month, we had a “kitty clearance” where we offered cats at discounted prices. The ‘inn’ was full and we had to make room. We placed over 70 kittens and cats and several dogs. Good thing, because as soon as the shelter was relieved, along came more. This morning’s email from the shelter announced our dog kennels are full again (2 purebred-Husky & Jack Russell); our cat cages are also full again. We may end up with another “clearance” before the end of the year.

      I believe the breeding business needs better regulation when it comes to kittens not fit for showing. Otherwise, more lives will be lost and more shelters’ budgets will be strained.

      • Very good idea. Cat breeders should not be allowed to clog up shelters with unwanted cats. Although I don’t know how commonplace it is. They should be under an obligation to find homes on their own. The whole concept of cat breeding is debatable when millions of cats are killed at shelters. To abandon purebred cats at shelters is ridiculous and obviously immoral.

        • Unfortunately, Michael, it is more commonplace than you think. In our case, the 2 purebred dogs were reclaimed by their owners. The purebred cats are usually the 1st to leave shelters; however, our volunteers have migrated into different roles. I specialize in placing kittens and young adults, another specializes in adopting out adult cats; yet another specializes in placing hard-to-place cats like those with continual medical issues/hospice and the senior cats. It was never assigned that way, it just sort of worked out that way.

          Even with a strong network of other shelters and the public, these abandoned cats are still languishing, awaiting their forever homes.

          We’ve got a local TV news celebrity who helps us periodically get the word out. I wonder, do other shelters have similar experiences?

          • I am sad to hear that, Gail. Are you saying that a noticeable number of breeders get rid of unwanted purebred cats at shelters? If so what percentage? Or how many come in over 6 months or a month? I would like to know some detail 🙂 please. Thanks for the comment by the way.

            • It’s difficult to say whether purebreds we get are from breeders, as most people claim they’re ‘good Samaritans’ – who are we to say otherwise? In a 6/month period, I’d say our shelter gets 2 or 3, but there may be more; we just can’t prove it.

              Over the past 3 years I’ve been at the shelter, I’ve seen breeds such as Sphynx, Tiffany, Munchkin, Siamese, Maine Coon (not a mix), Persian (owner reclaimed her; change of heart) and 2 Ragdolls. So far, the red Sphynx was the favorite – we had a waiting line of apps on her! She lasted less than a week! As soon as the vet cleared her, out the door she went! Those huge, bright, intelligent, green jade eyes were haunting.

      • The saddest thing we ever experienced was losing several kittens to panleuk. It was spreading through the shelter at such a fast rate that over 100 kittens under the age of 4 months had to be euthanized. Then a few weeks later the shelter had to euthanize at least 50 more kittens and cats for the same reason. I feel for my friend who does such a great job finding rescues for the cats and also does adoption events. It’s her decision who has to be euthanized. I’d go crazy if I had to do that. We don’t do rescue anymore. We have a comfortable number of cats and our lives are centered around them. We have cat trees and cat beds everywhere and couldn’t be happier. We saved over 50 lives so we feel we’ve done our part. The mess back in July ended our rescue, even though we were cleared of any wrongdoing. It’s sad because we had began fostering and could have helped many more cats.

  16. Wow, how cold hearted. I’m surprised that it seems that this is an every day thing. How horrible.

  17. We adopted a Maine coon kitten from a rescue group. Most loving cat! Had no idea what a Maine coon cat was before I read about him. He grew big really fast, loved water and his tail looked like a raccoons. Well we had him for almost 4 years and one night his paw went limp! Rushed him to emergency vet said it was a heart condition. He had full on heart disease genetic disorder that is common in these breeds. No warning or prevention. We wonder since breeders do the genetic testing before selling these if that’s how he ended up in the shelter.
    I miss him everyday. RIP Kobe

    • What a sad story Carolyn. Kobe was a handsome cat. Some breeders are not that good. Some are bad. And some cat owners are unsuited to caring for a cat and so the end result is a lovely Maine Coon ends up in a shelter where anything could happen.

      Breeders tend to ignore genetic health issues and brush them under the carpet and focus on appearance at all costs. Not all breeders do that but the poorer ones do.

      Thanks for sharing Carolyn.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Please only upload photos that are small in size of max 500px width and 50 KB size. Large images typical of most default settings on digital cameras may fail to upload. Thanks.