Categories: Jaguar

Black Panther caught on video in Sydney’s North Shore? is probably taking the piss but they might be genuine but mistaken. They have a story about a university student capturing on video a large, black domestic cat (in my considered view) which has been described as a “black panther”. Black panthers normally refer to melanistic jaguars i.e. black jaguars. If the phrase doesn’t refer to a jaguar it refers to a leopard and occassionally a puma. All are large wild cats.

Black panther or domestic or feral cat? This is a cleaned up and annotated version of the screenshot on the website.

The story quotes an expert who has decided that the cat in question weighs up to 20 kg. The Jaguar can weigh up to over a hundred kilograms and is certainly many times more than 20 kg. We don’t have to rely on an expert and his assessment of the weight of the animal. Visually, this cat could never be a jaguar or a leopard. It is certainly a very large domestic or feral cat. It may be semi-feral. There are many very large domestic and in Australia feral cats. They can certainly weigh 25+ pounds which is 11+ kgs.

The newspaper says that the video (which I can’t embed on this website) confirms what has long been part of Aussie folklore that there is a big black cat wandering around the urban environment. Like I said I think they are taking the piss. People have this innate fear of the big cats. I am sure that it is inherited from times when early humans genuinely had to contend with fearsome predators.

The person who captured the video footage is Alex McDonald. He said the cat was behind the San Hospital in Wahroonga and that it looked about 1 m plus long. That’s his assessment. He is saying that the cat was more than 3 feet in length, approximately. Typically, people exaggerate when they make these sort of observations at a distance. They exaggerate because they want to believe that the animal is a large big cat. Even at 3+ feet it is way too small to be a jaguar which is between 1.3 and 1.6 m in length excluding the tail.

The story is simply not credible. There is another point to make. The way that domestic or feral cats walk i.e. their gait gives away their species. The big cats walk in a very particular manner. It is slightly lumbering and less dainty. There is positively no way that this cat is walking like a jaguar or leopard.

It is surprising that the comments on the newspaper’s webpage includes some by people who actually believe that it is a big cat. I’m afraid that they are mistaken. I have never been able to confirm that any of the sightings of mysterious big cats are genuine. Not one has been proved to be true. That, too, also proves a point that these creatures do not exist in reality but in the minds of fearful people.

Link to the story.


‘Clear picture’ of puma in British countryside is a domestic cat (as usual)

This is meant to be one of the clearest photos of a 'wild puma' ever seen in Britain...ugh. It was ...
Read More

Big cat sighting in Southern Italy is likely to be genuine

This is one of the few possibly genuine big cat sightings in Europe. So often they are domestic cats. There ...
Read More

Missouri Department of Conservation make the effort to prove mountain lion sighting is incorrect

It is unusual for a state department to become involved like this in taking the time and trouble to prove ...
Read More

Fear of big cats turns moggies into mountain lions

Because of the human's fear of big cats inherited from our ancient ancestors (when they really were a cause for ...
Read More

This is a joke or people are delusional. This black domestic cat is not a ‘beast’

Please God spare me this nonsense. Get some glasses please, and acquire some common sense. I must be taking it ...
Read More

Cat with 5 inch paws kills five pet cats

Cornwall, UK: they are in a frenzy. Rumours are spreading and the police are saying that it could be true ...
Read More

Outsized moggy – Beast of St Albans – is no bigger than my cat!

Thirteen days ago the Daily Mail online presented to the world a mysterious cat which they described as the Beast ...
Read More
Michael Broad

Hi, I'm a 71-year-old retired solicitor (attorney in the US). Before qualifying I worked in many jobs including professional photography. I have a girlfriend, Michelle. I love nature, cats and all animals. I am concerned about their welfare.

Recent Posts

A nursing mother’s nipples are labelled like school lockers for her kittens

The language I've used in the title comes from that wonderful writer, Desmond Morris. He…

2 hours ago

Young man in an apartment in Spain rescued two cats and had 96 three years later

A young man has been evicted from his 1,000 square-foot apartment in the seaside town…

2 hours ago

Free credit to help pay your veterinary bill

A little while ago I wrote about the choice between taking out an pet health…

3 hours ago

Animal rescue crew search around burnt out homes and discover a surviving cat

CALIFORNIA WILDFIRES 15 SEPT 2020 - CHICO: Cat lovers will be pleased to know that…

1 day ago

Another nail in the coffin of free-roaming domestic cats?

NEWS AND ANALYSIS: if you read the online news media on the subject of cats…

1 day ago

Should I get a covered litter box?

The general consensus is that you should not get a covered litter box. Although I…

2 days ago