Can a vegan diet for a cat be acceptable?

I’m going to play devil’s advocate and write something provocative. Can a vegan (or vegetarian) diet for a cat be acceptable? I believe that it is a question worth asking. I don’t think that we should criticise the idea of feeding your cat a vegan diet out of hand without thinking about it carefully. And the fact that they exist and no one has sued the manufacturers is perhaps telling.

Vegetarian cat food

The reason why I say this is because we know that cats have specific dietary requirements and the nutrients that they require come from eating animals. However, a veterinary specialist in animal welfare science and the Professor of Animal Welfare and Ethics at the University of Winchester (Australia) makes an important point. He says that there is a difference between specific dietary ingredients and specific dietary nutrients.

Provided a plant-based diet has been formulated to meet all of the palatability, nutritional and bioavailability needs of a cat then it should be satisfactory. Yes, he is saying is that if you take a plant-based pet food and add to it the specific nutrients that domestic cats require, during its manufacturer, then it should be satisfactory

There are, on the market, commercially available vegan companion animal diets which do this. Apparently, studies have demonstrated that animals (and I presume he includes domestic cats) can be perfectly healthy when feeding on nutritionally sound vegan diets. He refers to a study by Knight & Leitsberger carried out in 2016.

Now I know that cat lovers will hate the idea of the suggestion that it is possible to make a commercially prepared cat food based on plants. However, there may be advantages because we know that existing cat food is often based on very poor quality ingredients even though they are meat-based.

There is a guy in Australia, Harry Bolman, who received a barrage of abuse online when it got out that he feeds his cat a carefully prepared vegan diet. He said:

‘Uma is my first cat…she has been a vegan cat ever since I first adopted her. She absolutely loves a vegan diet. I will boil some pumpkin and mash it up with the dry vegan cat food and she chows it down like there is no tomorrow. Uma is very healthy.” (I presume the reference to ‘dry vegan cat food’ is a dry commercially available food he buys locally)

He goes on to say that his cat has a great appetite and is full of vitality. He complains about regular processed commercially available cat food which he describes as abysmal. He said:

“It’s just bits and pieces of different animals which is absolutely revolting. There is no way out feed my cat that”.

I get his point by the way. Like I said it’s about nutrients rather than ingredients. The important question is: does the food contain the required nutrients to sustain a domestic cat? As long as the manufacturers have included essential amino acids such as taurine and arginine, is it fair to criticise a person who is feeding their cat a vegan diet?

I know that a person who is a vegan cannot justify feeding their cat a vegan diet because they are a vegan. It is wrong to impose one’s ideology upon a companion animal. However if the argument is changed to criticise existing cat food (and it can be criticised) and say that a specialist vegan diet formulated for a cat might be better, I think is difficult to argue against that.

The counterargument is made by a veterinary surgeon writing for The Telegraph newspaper. His name is Dr Pete Wedderburn. He is not convinced that a commercial non-meat cat diet has been proven to be adequate through proper feeding trials. He is not convinced that such a product is available at the moment. He makes the classic argument that it is wrong for strict vegan cat owners to force their cats to be vegan.

If you are sharing a home with an obligate carnivore he argues that it is unfair to ask them to change their natural way of feeding to fit your personal beliefs. Yes, I agree with that wholeheartedly but I’m not sure that it is correct to say that a satisfactory commercially available vegan cat food is not yet on the market. Also, as mentioned, if you put aside the personal beliefs of the cat owner and focus on the cat food is it not beyond the bounds of one’s imagination to see that a vegan cat food with supplemental nutrients is okay?

What do you think? I’m not supporting either party. I’m just discussing the subject and asking questions.

7 thoughts on “Can a vegan diet for a cat be acceptable?”

  1. A vegan dry food is apt to cause serious urinary tract issues in cats–something PETA knows very well. There is a long list of nutrients cats need (besides taurine) that aren’t provided by a vegan diet. I have seen some pretty sick cats who were forced to eat a vegan diet. Don’t do it.

    Reply
  2. Dr Pete Wedderburn has a great point. For example: Protein is protein, right?

    WRONG! Plant protein is molecularly different from animal protein. This results in inadequate nutrition for the carnivorous pet.

    Moral of the story? Feed your pet a species specific diet and forego your opinion. You don’t want me to force my opinion on you, so why are you forcing yours on someone who can’t speak human?

    Reply
  3. “It’s just bits and pieces of different animals which is absolutely revolting. There is no way out feed my cat that”.

    Without getting into the what the hell is in that can of cat food cats that eat small prey eat the whole animal not just the choice cuts. So we need to get beyond our often warped sense that it’s OK to kill an animal for food but be repulsed by 3/4 of it.
    As to a vegan diet for your cat as stated before if you can’t handle the tins of meat get a different pet. This is humans trying to modify a well developed species to their needs not the cats. Poor stewardship at it’s best.

    Reply
  4. Interesting discussion. I can thoroughly understand the nutrient theory. There is one point that enters my mind concerning a feline vegan diet. It is documented that cats, as in other carnivores, have a shorter intestinal length, in relation to body length, than do omnivores and herbivores. The ratio is said to be 4:1. However they have a greater absorptive capacity, making digestion of fibers and starches only 10% less efficient. Obviously the majority of cats left to their own devices will choose live prey, which greatly contributes to their daily water requirements. I do not feel conclusive either way concerning this topic.

    http://veterinarycalendar.dvm360.com/cats-obligate-carnivore-proceedings

    Reply
    • Thanks Frances. I agree it is a tricky subjects to discuss. Perhaps that is why I’m discussing it. I, too, and ambivalent about whether a vegan diet is acceptable to a cat even if it is manufactured to a high standard and contains all the required nutrients. I just feel that people should not say such a diet is completely hopeless and useless. I don’t think that it is as black-and-white as that. Perhaps that is the underlying point that I wish to make.

      Reply
  5. Provocative, yes. Nutritionally sound? Not so much. Cat food in supermarkets are just crap; there’s no getting around it. That’s why cats should be given higher quality food, without all of the chemicals, bone meal, etc. I read EVERYTHING on the labels, including percentages of ingredients. I am not convinced that a vegan diet has been proven to be sufficiently acceptable to cats nutrition-wise. It’s only been a couple years of testing – not long enough for my own cats’ diet. Mine are fed both wet and dry. The wet is a high quality brand, without chemicals and junk. The dry is a nutritionally sound, low fat brand (not found in local green grocers/supermarkets) and is limited in feeding. Both of my cats, ages nine and ten still behave as if they’re kittens, even the one who’s FIV+. That’s proof enough for me.

    Reply

Leave a Comment

follow it link and logo