Categories: hoarders

Cat hoarders need talking therapy treatment (CBT)

We need to focus for a while on the perpetrators of cat hoarding as well as the victims. My primary focus is on the cats because I am interested in cat welfare. However, almost daily we encounter a story of cat hoarding in online news media. The Anxiety and Depression Association of America reports that local authorities in the US deal with 3,500 animal hoarders annually and a quarter of a million animals are affected.

A cat hoarder’s cats. Pinterest.

Clearly something needs to be done to try and stop this abuse of animals. I have never read in news stories or anywhere else online of cat hoarders receiving treatment for their mental health. If the focus is on the hoarder it is to do with punishment and the confiscation of their cats to a rescue facility. Rarely do we read of follow ups. It is almost certain that within a year of having her/his cats confiscated she is back to where she was before surrounded by a hoard of cats in filthy conditions.

The consensus is that cat hoarding is a mental health issue. It is similar to any other form of hoarding. It might have to be classified as a particular form of hoarding but the underlying mental health issues are similar. For example, up to 40% of ‘object hoarders’ also hoard animals.

And, critically, all cat hoarders relapse to their old ways without treatment.

Cat hoarders rarely seek treatment. Therefore they have to be either forced by court order or encouraged to do so by relatives. They have an inability to take decisions to improve their lives. The hoarder is firmly in a deep rut, engaged as they are in round the clock animal care which is failing disastrously.

My research indicates that the only current, effective treatment available is cognitive behaviour treatment (CBT). In a study entitled: Waitlist-Controlled Trial of Cognitive Behavior Therapy for Hoarding Disorder by Gail Steketee (and colleagues) the conclusion was that ‘Multi-component CBT was effective in treating hoarding. However, treatment refusal and compliance remain a concern…’

Locked up feelings. Pinterest.

Also the NHS in England say that CBT has been shown to be effective in treating some mental conditions such as OCD and phobias which for me are in a similar category of mental disorder as cat hoarding.

I would like to see reports on (1) courts ordering prosecuted cat hoarders to attend a course of CBT treatment and (2) further studies on the treatment of cat hoarders with CBT.

The authorities need to be more involved in tackling the root cause of cat hoarding as well. Studies tell us that cat hoarding often starts after a traumatic event such as an illness, death of a significant other or disability. Perhaps some sort of intervention (support) early on may turn potential hoarders away from this form of compulsive behaviour.

Finally there is an argument that local ordinances (laws) might be strengthened to place barriers in the way of cat hoarders in acquiring cats e.g. limits on the number of cats allowed. These laws will be controversial but there is also a need to improve cat caretaking to reduce the number of unwanted cats. Specific laws on cat rescue may be the answer as hoarders consider themselves to be cat rescuers. In fact they think they are on a mission to save the lives of cats. This distinguishing them from object hoarders who hoard in case they need the item.

On finally point; having lots of cats does not automatically make the person a cat hoarder. Some people care for many cats to an excellent standard. A characteristic of cat hoarding is a failure to maintain cat welfare standards while being insensitive to this failure.

Please comment here using either Facebook or WordPress (when available).
Michael Broad

Hi, I am 70-years-of-age at 2019. For 14 years before I retired at 57, I worked as a solicitor in general law specialising in family law. Before that I worked in a number of different jobs including professional photography. I have a longstanding girlfriend, Michelle. We like to walk in Richmond Park which is near my home because I love nature and the landscape (as well as cats and all animals).

View Comments

  • I totally agree Michael. The removal of animals from a cat hoarder's home only attempts to treat the ongoing problem. The cat hoarder in many, if not most, cases will revert back to the same behavior. Definitely a new approach is needed to address the emotional aspects of this condition. The innocent animal souls are the ones suffering intense physical and psychological neglect and therefore abuse, which quite often leads to their tragic death.

    • Thanks Frances. I don't see great steps being made to address the root causes of cat hoarding or to treat the hoarders. It is the same in the UK. No one can preach to anyone else. I am sure it is a universal problem. One study on this took place in Brazil for instance.

Recent Posts

Second domestic cat tests positive for Covid-19

Currently there is no evidence that companion animals can be a source of the virus.…

1 hour ago

Picture of a Chinese desert cat a.k.a. Chinese mountain cat

This cat should be called the Chinese steppe cat (an area of flat, unforested grassland).…

2 hours ago

How a nursing home cat had the unusual ability of predicting death within the next hours

You may remember Oscar. He is quite famous (actually very famous). He's a fluffy, grey-and-white…

7 hours ago

Netflix film about the battle between Big Cat Rescue and Joe Exotic is a big hit

It's been reported that the feud over big cats between Joe Exotic and Carole Baskin,…

8 hours ago

Are cheetahs solitary?

The social organisation of cheetahs is unique among the wild cat species. Females are solitary…

12 hours ago

Talking about a cat at a distance because of social isolation

LEEDS, UK: Pictures of a conversation, posted on Twitter, between neighbours at a distance through…

12 hours ago