Categories: Cat Health

Cat vaccination – an example

by Michael

This is an example of what can go wrong with respect to cat vaccination. It resulted in litigation – a court case or law suit, which at the time of writing (Feb. 2012) is still proceeding; hence the need to write carefully.

A lot us know by now that feline vaccinations, that were once thought of as obligatory and given routinely as boosters are no longer the wonder medicine that we thought they were. Certain vaccinations in certain countries are obligatory (rabies vaccination) but there is dispute about the need to routinely administer other vaccines.

Recommendations are now provided as to the place on the cat where the vaccination is administered in new medical procedures to minimize negative side effects one of which is VAS – “vaccine associated sarcoma”.

The vaccine can cause cancer, to put it in layperson’s terminology, which is what is alleged to have happened to a cat called, Kitty Kat.

Kitty Kat lived with Jena Gonzalez and she is suing her former veterinarian for professional negligence, malpractice as well as negligent misrepresentation.

Her expert witness is Dr Bob Rogers. I received an email about this matter and was asked to forward it or post it to colleagues. Posting it here is probably better.

Jena Gonzalez alleges that she was not advised properly by her vet and was not therefore able to provide informed consent to the vaccinations. She would have refused the vaccinations if given informed consent, she says.

It is claimed that Kitty Kat was given “two unnecessary vaccines, an adjuvanted PLPRhCv vaccination at a two year interval and an adjuvanted FeLV vaccine to an adult cat.”

Despite Jena Gonzalez’s best efforts in funding surgery and chemotherapy Kitty Kat died 2.14.11.

Jena is seeking help in funding legal costs expected to be $10,000.

I think this law suit is important because I also think that there is a lot of over-vaccination going on vets in the USA, UK and Europe. It is a good earner for the vets.

The case may help to alter the attitude towards feline vaccination that seems to be prevalent at veterinary surgeries in the West generally.

I am pleased to say that my local vet, in Barnes, London (Vets at White Hart Lane) did not recommend that my cat, Charlie be vaccinated despite going out occasionally because the area is quite affluent and it is likely that cats in the area are vaccinated resulting in protection for other cats i.e. the diseases are in check in the area. This advice strongly indicated to me that I have an excellent veterinarian who is thinking about the health of animals in his charge and not simply being formulaic in the interests of enhancing profits.

Donations to help pay legal fees

“Donations are tax deductible and can be made to the NPO C.A.R.E.S., (Critter Advocacy Responsibility Ethics Science)( ) at 5703 Louetta Rd. Spring, Texas 77379.” – Bob Rogers who is providing his services pro bono (free of charge).

My research indicates that one in one thousand cats die of cancer caused by a vaccination. The source is Cat Owner’s Home Veterinary Guide.


Comments for
Cat vaccination – an example

Click here to add your own comments

Mar 07, 2012 My cat was a victim, too NEW
by: Anonymous

I, too, know your pain. The anger I have even to this day — 13 years after my little boy’s death, is indescribable (perhaps because my vet was a personal friend of mine and I could never imagine him doing something that would hurt my baby). I’ve learned from this that vets can and should be assumed to be ignorant until proven otherwise. I’ve learned to do my own research and am familiar with such names as Ronald Schultz, Jean Dodds, Bob Rogers. I’ve learned that when we know better we do better, and I celebrate the memory or my boy in the lives of the beautiful creatures who entered my life after another was torn from me needlessly. My thoughts are with you in your (our) battle for legal justice.

Kitty Kat, que en paz descanso

Feb 26, 2012 Vet Negligence NEW
by: Jena Gonzalez

Thank you for posting my story. Please visit my site and help support our efforts to hold veterinarians accountable.

Michael Broad

Hi, I'm a 71-year-old retired solicitor (attorney in the US). Before qualifying I worked in a many jobs including professional photography. I have a girlfriend, Michelle. I love nature, cats and all animals. I am concerned about their welfare.

Leave a Comment

Recent Posts

How do cats spread ringworm?

Ringworm (dermatophytosis) is spread by cats in direct contact with each other or with materials that have been contaminated with…

2 hours ago

Adopt a cat from a reputable source

Dr Bruce Fogle in his book Complete Cat Care provides us with some nice tips about the kind of place…

6 hours ago

Some staff at Cats Protection resigning over the organisation’s kill policy

CAT NEWS & VIEWS: There appears to be dissent amongst some of the volunteers at the well-known cat rescue organisation,…

10 hours ago

Ghislaine Maxwell’s cat injured when FBI smashed down her front door

CAT NEWS AND VIEWS: Ghislaine Maxwell's rescue cat was injured and ran off when 60 armed FBI agents and police…

12 hours ago

Factors affecting the success rate of shelter cat adoptions

Not all cat adoptions from animal shelters are successful. They don't lead to a relationship for the lifespan of the…

1 day ago

Is it true that cats go away to die?

I have to say that the question is poorly formulated. There is an element of truth about it but it's…

1 day ago