Categories: Cat News

Couple charged with animal cruelty are suing to get some of their cats back

Pamela Arrington and Garriott Cox are a couple whose behaviour has been extensively reported online in news outlets. They’ve been charged with animal cruelty. The authorities found 74 dead cats and 150 live cats and other animals in a (their?) home in Middle River, Baldwin, Maryland, USA. Many of the cats were taken to the county shelter in Baldwin which, understandably, put the facilities under pressure. Animal services say that they are holding 19 cats until a decision has been made on whether they can be returned to Arrington and Cox.

Cox and Arrington. Mugshots in the public domain.

Therefore, animal services are considering returning 19 cats to this couple who have been charged with animal cruelty. To someone like me, this begs the obvious question as to whether on ethical grounds animal services should even consider returning some cats to this couple.

However, perhaps the answer to the issue is to wait until their trial has been completed to see whether they are convicted or acquitted. If acquitted then there may be good reason to return the 19 cats on hold.

However, if that’s the case, and that is the logical way to proceed in my opinion, Arrington and Cox have filed their claim against the county prematurely. There’s no point in them asking for a court order that their cats are returned before it has been decided whether they are guilty or not. If they are found guilty it would be mad to return some of their cats too them even if the rescue services are full-up.

Normally, in these situations, the evidence is very clear cut because the cats are rescued and removed from a house which is in a poor condition and where there are many cats who been neglected. It is more or less cut and dried and therefore to be charged is almost as good as being convicted. The evidence is usually that strong.

On that basis, if I was in charge of animal control I would tell the couple right away that there is no chance of them getting their cats back even at the outset and even before the criminal trial has been brought to a conclusion.

Please comment here using either Facebook or WordPress (when available).
Michael Broad

Hi, I am 70-years-of-age at 2019. For 14 years before I retired at 57, I worked as a solicitor in general law specialising in family law. Before that I worked in a number of different jobs including professional photography. I have a longstanding girlfriend, Michelle. We like to walk in Richmond Park which is near my home because I love nature and the landscape (as well as cats and all animals).

Recent Posts

Top ten cat breeds CFA 2019

This is the current ranking of the most popular cat breeds recognised by the Cat…

5 hours ago

Mystery cat picture. What is it?

It took me a little while to figure what was happening in this photograph. The…

12 hours ago

Woman combs and cuddles an enormous Eurasian lynx (video)

We are not told what species of cat this is so I'll speculate. I believe…

13 hours ago

Massive muzzle on Maine Coon (picture)

This is another extraordinary looking Maine Coon. I have described the cat's muzzle as massive.…

18 hours ago

Picture of black Sphynx ‘alien’ kitten and false pink nails


19 hours ago

Quiz on the origin of the Persian cat

Please follow the instructions. There is one question and ten possible answers one of which…

1 day ago