Is there a connection between feline vaccine overdose and pancreatitis? I’m told by veterinary experts that more than 90% of all pancreatitis cases in the cat have no identifiable cause.
In other words, veterinarians do not know what causes feline pancreatitis. That would seem to be a sorry state of affairs and one which should be rectified. There are a number of mysterious cat illnesses. I mean we don’t know what causes them. This got me thinking.
There is a lot of discussion about vaccinations and the risk and rewards that they bring. I researched the issue as to whether feline vaccine overdose could cause pancreatitis. I discovered that, unsurprisingly, veterinarians have conflicting ideas on the subject.
Dr Marcia’s blog usefully refers to studies conducted on humans which indicate a possible connection between vaccines and pancreatitis in dogs (and cats, I would presume). She makes the point that the pathology is very similar in cats, dogs and humans in terms of this subject.
Dr Marcia says that we used to blame high fat foods for pancreatitis in pets. She also says that there is an alarming increase in pancreatitis in cats and dogs. This occurs even when the pet is on a low-fat prescription diet.
Dr Marcia suggests, in her blog, that a common denominator is “recent or repeated vaccination”.
She states that in human research studies, “histamine release triggered during vaccination causes damage to the pancreas”. She states that she has not seen pancreatitis in a dog who has been “minimally vaccinated”.
She is not saying that there is a certain connection between cat and dog pancreatitis and over-vaccinating. She simply suggesting that there may be a connection and it should be looked into.
The comments to her online article are interesting because another veterinarian – a well-known veterinarian with an internet presence, Dr Paul Jaffe DVM – argues that what Dr Marcia is stating in her blog is dangerous because it undermines pet vaccination as a means of preventing disease.
Dr Jaffe gently criticises Dr Marcia for not presenting evidence-based medical arguments. He criticises her for going along with a gut feeling rather than being more scientific.
You can read Dr Marcia’s blog by clicking on this link. The discussion between two veterinarians is interesting. And I don’t think Dr Marcia is being anything other than genuinely concerned for animal welfare. It does show that more work needs to be done on the causes of feline pancreatitis.
In addition to the possible link between over-vaccinating and feline pancreatitis, it is argued that a high carb kibble diet may play a role in pancreatitis in cats and dogs.
Is there a pet health problem with pet owners stopping all vaccines because they are reading information on the internet which puts them off vaccinating their cats and dogs?
The truth of the matter is that more work is required on vaccinations and on their benefits and detriments but also we need to remind ourselves that vaccinations are about risk and reward. They do prevent illness but they also carry a risk of creating an illness themselves.
The general consensus is obvious: that vaccinations provide an overall benefit to feline and canine health otherwise they wouldn’t exist. But I have a hunch that over-vaccinating could be one of the unrecognized causes of a number of feline illnesses including feline pancreatitis.