Feral Cat Control: TVHR Better than TNR

TVHR is more effective than TNR, a study concludes.

This is an interesting study that looks at a modified version of Trap-Neuter-Return (TNR) to make it more effective. The good thing is that the study takes TNR seriously as a way to manage feral cat colonies. The study indirectly validates the concept of TNR, which to sterilise the cats and leave them where they are. A humane process. Note: the study1 was a computer simulation. The objective is to carry it out in real life.

So what is TVHR and how does it differ from TNR?

TNR

TNR is well known but it helps to spell out the process. TNR can be called: Trap-Test-Vaccinate-Alter-Release (TTVAR) – “alter” means to neuter (male) or spay (female). The neutering bit of TNR is:

  • male: neutering: testicles removed – castration
  • female: spaying: removal of the uterus and ovaries

TVHR

The letters stand for Trap-Vasectomies or Hysterectomies-Release

  • male: a vasectomy: the tube that carries the sperm is cut
  • female: hysterectomy: this is the same as spaying, removal of ovaries and uterus.

The difference between TNR and TVHR is that the male cat is sterilised by castration for TNR and has “the snip” for TVHR.

How can this slight difference make a bit difference in the management of feral cats?

Firstly, the research indicates the following:

ProcessPercentage of cats undergoing processEffect after 11 years
TVHR35% of catsPopulation of colony would disappear
TNR82% of catsPopulation of colony would disappear

Why is this? Apparently there are two reasons:

  1. Feral cat colonies – a group of cats – are controlled by a dominant male. If this cat undergoes a vasectomy he retains his sexual hormones and sex drive (as opposed to the castrated cat). He, therefore mates with the females but produces no kittens. If he had been castrated instead he would lose his sex drive and another dominant, breeding, male feral cat would take over the dominant position and seek out females, creating kittens.
  2. Also, an intact (non-spayed) female who has mated with a vasectomised male undergoes a 45-day period of pseudo-pregnancy, which is a further barrier to reproduction.

Well, there it is. This is not a magic formula but the study does promote the humane concept of trapping and sterilising feral cats as opposed to simply killing them.

The one downside of TVHR is that the males behave as if they are breeding cats so their behavior is more intrusive for people living in the location of the colony.


Ref: (1) as reported on the website news.nationalgeographic.com (I don’t have a link to the original study, sorry).

11 thoughts on “Feral Cat Control: TVHR Better than TNR”

  1. The author of the best comment will receive an Amazon gift of their choice at Christmas! Please comment as they can add to the article and pass on your valuable experience.
  2. In your previous comments (which due to time constraints I skimmed) I get the impression that you don’t believe legislation is the answer to dealing with less than adequate cat ownership but education is the solution. If that is true I disagree because although education is the answer, some people need to be forced to change. Only enforced laws can achieve that. TNR is good but the local authorities are slow to adopt it. There are still many detractors – people who dislike cats and who want the cats killed and irresponsible cat owners punished. TNR leaves cats on the street. It is long term. People don’t see results.

  3. Hi Christine. Thanks for sharing. For the record your links are tagged with “nofollow” which stops any PR benefit being gained. I have to do this to stop spam which is endemic.

  4. Please see expert analysis of this TVHR study and it’s implications, by Peter Wolf of Vox Felina and Best Friends Animal Society:

    Reductio ad absurdum

    “Results of a new computer model suggest that sterilization via vasectomy and hysterectomy is more effective than traditional spay/neuter at reducing the population of community cats. But the work raises several questions about the model’s validity—and more troubling ones about its implications for animal welfare.”

    – see http://www.voxfelina.com/2013/08/tufts-researchtrap-vasectomy-hysterectomy-release/

    “JAVMA Letter: A Trojan Horse”
    – All Dollars, No Sense

    http://www.voxfelina.com/2013/12/javma-letter-to-the-editor-feral-cat-management/

  5. Several nuisance behaviours of intact cats are noted by Cats Protection in this pdf. Other than population control, TVHR would not address these issues. I think CP forgot to mention that female cats can also spray urine when they’re in heat, though it’s not nearly as pungent as tomcat urine and so less noticeable outside. Cat owners may be surprised if they’re not aware that this can be normal behaviour of intact female cats.

    http://www.cats.org.uk/uploads/documents/cat-care-leaflets-2013/EG06_Neutering.pdf

    I agree with more enlightened cat adoption groups, that cats with FIV deserve to live. We need to neuter, not simply do vasectomies, if we are going to help stop cats from fighting and getting infections from bite wounds. Several vets and groups still don’t even bother trying to adopt out these deserving cats who can live just as long as FIV negative cats.

    Photo of Bud from a non-commercial info resource page on FIV, in Bud’s memory- http://www.FIVtherapy.com
    Credit – the website’s author.

Leave a Comment

follow it link and logo