I believe that a lot of aggression against cats is as a result of redirected human aggression. As I understand it, most cat abuse is perpetrated by young men. Historically, young men are angry. Not all young men are angry but a lot of them are. They are perhaps justifiably angry for one reason or another. Perhaps their parents were rubbish or the father died young. Perhaps the world that they live in is unjust and too demanding for them. They have difficulty coping.
They become angry. They want to strike out at society. They can’t release their aggressive towards a person because they will usually be caught, charged, convicted and punished for anything from an assault to a murder.
However, it is very easy to be abusive towards a cat that’s wandering outside which, to these people, might provide some temporary relief to the anger that they feel.
We know, and I have constantly mentioned it, cats outside are incredibly vulnerable one way and another. They are ideal targets against which a person wishing to do violence can express that violence and get away with it through lack of eyewitnesses and police commitment. Also, some cat owners are so laissez-faire that when their cat goes missing they simply keep quiet and do nothing about it. This supports cat abuse on the streets.
There are many instances of married or unmarried couples arguing where the man takes out his frustration and anger on the woman’s cat companion. This is arguably a form of redirected aggression.
For the sake of clarity, redirected aggression in cats is when a cat might become aggressive because of a number of reasons one of which could be that a strange cat walks outside the window, in his territory. The cat becomes frustrated and cannot get at the stranger cat and therefore turns his aggression towards his human owner. Or in a multi-cat household one cat may become temporarily aggressive towards another cat. A human might intervene and the cat’s aggression is redirected at the human.
My argument is that humans also suffer from redirected aggression and the victim is quite often the stray, vulnerable cat.
What may be an act of human redirected aggression towards a cat occured when a New York man, 45-year-old John Gehrlein, almost decapitated a cat. He was charged and convicted of the felony of aggravated animal cruelty. He could not provide an explanation as to why he did it.
Source: my own thoughts and for the case report: Dertoit Free Press.