Categories: hoarders

No crime for woman who hoarded 105 cats in apartment

Guelph, Ontario, Canada: report that a woman living in an apartment had surrendered 105 cats to the Guelph Humane Society last week.

The matter was investigated by the Provincial Animal Welfare Services (PAWS) who decided there would be no criminal charges.

Their inspector attended the property. The owner relinquished all of her cats to the Guelph Humane Society (GHS) who said that some of them need medical care. Some basic medical care has been administered such as vaccines, de-fleaing and microchipping. The cats are not yet ready for adoption. All-in-all a fairly standard cat hoarding case except no charges under animal welfare legislation.


It appears that GHS were notified first and decided that PAWS needed to investigate. Therefore GHS decided that there was a potential crime (of animal cruelty) that needed to be investigated.

The interesting aspect of this rather typical story of cat hoarding is that the hoarder was not charged under animal welfare laws despite the concerns of GHS.

We don’t have hard details so we can’t comment on that but on the website their readers have the opportunity to have their say through clicking on a set range of options which I have reproduced below.

The results are interesting as the predominant emotion is anger and the second more common emotion is happiness.

Reaction of readers to story that a cat hoarder of 105 cats was not charged with an animal cruelty crime. It happened in Canada. The circumstances justified the decision although it is unusual.

Clearly the angry ones believe that the hoarder should have been charged (punished) while the happy ones are pleased that the cats were rescued and perhaps that there were no charges.

The results don’t surprise me as there is a general tendency to be angry at cat hoarders who often neglect the welfare of their cats because they are overwhelmed. This causes animal suffering which in turn sometimes warrants punishment under animal welfare laws.

I suspect that in this instance the hoarder’s agreement to give up her cats, and because the cats were not in very poor health under the circumstances, PAWS decided to close the matter without charge. This can be the best solution and you can add in some help for the hoarder’s mental health if it is appropriate.


Picture of 130 ginger cats from one mother in one room apartment

I have never seen something like this: 130 cats, almost all ginger and ginger-and-white, all siblings from one mother who ...
Read More

How do you stop ‘things getting out of control’ at cat hoarding situations?

Hoarders often say it, 'things got out of control'. They are also the words of a man, Ryan Ross, who ...
Read More

Can you tell from their face that they are cat abusers?

We see mugshots of alleged cat abusers all the time. Or they are cat hoarders who neglect cats to the ...
Read More

A framework for eradicating cat hoarding in the United States of America

USA: You'll never get rid of cat hoarding under the current state of affairs. I realise that no one is ...
Read More

This man pleaded not guilty after 194 dead cats were found at his home

This is a very unusual animal abuse case and it has people scratching their heads as to how Dennis Carlson ...
Read More

Dozens of dead cats found in NY home. Why didn’t they let the cats go free?

This is a point made by a colleague of mine, Jan on Facebook, in reference to the story coming out ...
Read More

As a cat lover are you tired of seeing photos like this one?

I am reluctant to go into details into why we see this picture on the website but as usual ...
Read More
Please comment here using either Facebook or WordPress (when available).
Michael Broad

Hi, I am 70-years-of-age at 2019. For 14 years before I retired at 57, I worked as a solicitor in general law specialising in family law. Before that I worked in a number of different jobs including professional photography. I have a longstanding girlfriend, Michelle. We like to walk in Richmond Park which is near my home because I love nature and the landscape (as well as cats and all animals).

Recent Posts

Can a lynx kill a healthy adult human?

This is one of those debatable questions because as there are no records of lynx…

3 hours ago

People don’t want animals to be able to use language to communicate

The reason why people don't want animals to be able to communicate using language is…

6 hours ago

America’s Food And Drug Administration (FDA) allow their laboratory animals to be adopted

NEWS AND OPINION: In a change of policy, animals that the FDA has used for…

9 hours ago

Statewide declaw ban is government overreach?

Michigan state is debating a ban on declawing. If the legislation is passed Michigan would…

10 hours ago

Top ten cat breeds CFA 2019

This is the current ranking of the most popular cat breeds recognised by the Cat…

23 hours ago

Mystery cat picture. What is it?

It took me a little while to figure what was happening in this photograph. The…

1 day ago