Robert Neunzig DVM has declawed 2000 cats and he is proud of it
avatar

Robert Neunzig DVM

Robert Neunzig DVM

Dr Neunzig has written a blog in which he expresses his dismay at the American Association of Feline Practitioner’s (AAFP) harder stance against declawing. He wheels out the same old cliched arguments about greater abandonment of cats and more euthanasias if declawing is stopped.

There is no evidence that this happens. The opposite in fact. See for example the testimony below from a shelter director who is referring to another vet who declaws:

Shelter director testimony on declawed cat relinquishments

Shelter director testimony on declawed cat relinquishments


Please share this post to spread the word. Education on declawing is vital in the fight to stop it.


Dr Neunzig is one of those old dinosaur vets living in the past. Times have moved on. I think he needs to swat up on the consequences of declawing cats. He says that the pain it causes is temporary yet many other vets say that there are permanent negative consequences such as phantom pain and altered gait causing further issues such as arthritis.

He actually admits that the quality of declaw operations is poor. This compounds the immorality of the practice. In earlier posts I have mentioned the numerous botched declaw operations causing mountains of permanent pain in long suffering domestic cats.

Epidemic of Botched Cat Declaw Operations

He denies that declawed cats can tend to become biters. He denies that there are complications if the operation is carried out properly. He says that complications come from bad operations (of which there are many). I say he is wrong on that too because the operation is inherently hurtful to the cat.

He supports declawing because it stops cats destroying furniture. He says declawing prevents children being scratched when they pick up the family cat but does not consider the more moral alternative: educating the child to pick up the cat properly and respecting the cat and her claws. And accepting some damage to furniture: big deal. If you have a cat accept it or don’t have a cat. Simple.

He supports declawing to protect the elderly who are on blood thinners and who have compromised immune systems. He does not consider the possibility of these people not having a cat if they fall in the small bracket of the elderly with these conditions.

Clearly he has entrenched views about declawing. He fails to address the ethical issues. He fails to address the conflict between declawing and the veterinarian’s oath. He fails to address the potential for lifelong complications. He fails to address the fact that very many countries have banned it because it is cruel and is a breach of their general animal welfare laws. He fails to mention a European treaty which specifically bans declawing.

Dr Neunzig, I urge you to stick to the oath that you swore about 40 years ago to only treat animals when it is in their best interests and not to do it at the convenience of the cat’s owner. Please reconsider your attitude to this unnecessary mutilation.

Cat Declawing Myths and Truths

The doctor’s blog.

FB comments (see below)

Comments

Robert Neunzig DVM has declawed 2000 cats and he is proud of it — 11 Comments

  1. That is an excellent article, really punchy, you have more compassion in your toe nails than this rotting bag of faeces in human form with a paid up membership of Cruelty Incorporated aka the AVMA has, in his entire ugly, nasty body.

    I need mind bleach now. I can look away. If only the agonies of those 2000 poor,poor cats that he butchered could be stopped as simp!y as looking away.

    Bastard.

  2. No offense, but he looks like that Nazi doctor who experimented on children. God help the poor cats who cross his path. And SHAME on their selfish and foolish owners.

  3. Has this guy every heard of a scratching post? None of my cats have ever scratched the furniture! Maybe he needs his 10 fingers and toes cut off at the first knuckle!

    • Mine came scratching post trained – many thanks to fosters of the rescue. Both kittens went straight to the kitty tree and cardboard scratching pads, weren’t interested in anything else. Really, if a scratching post is good and sturdy, the cats will go for it. One time I saw a woman buying a very flimsy small scratching post. Why would any cat go for something like this when there is a good sturdy sofa available? A lot of people don’t understand that scratching post needs to be sturdy.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Please try and upload photos that are small in size of max 500px width and 50 KB size. Large images typical of most default settings on digital cameras may fail to upload. Thanks. Comment rules: (1) respect others (2) threatening, harassing, bullying, insulting and being rude to others is forbidden (3) advocating cat cruelty is forbidden (4) trolls (I know who they are) must use real name and upload a photo of themselves. Enforcement: (1) inappropriate comments are deleted before publication and (2) commenters who demonstrate a desire to flout the rules are banned. Failure to comply with (4) results in non-publication. Lastly, please avoid adding links because spam software regards comments with links as spam and holds them in the spam folder. I delete the spam folder contents daily.