Serial pet abuser and trader threatens animal welfare advocate in court

This is an interesting story about conflict between two people with very different attitudes towards companion animals.

On the one hand we have Gail Benoit, who sees companion animals as “things” to trade for profit without regard to health and welfare. She was convicted of animal cruelty for selling sick and malnourished puppies in 2009. In June 2014, Benoit was put on probation for 15 months for stealing and selling a couple of dogs from a woman in New Brunswick. She was selling online on the website: Kijiji at least on one occasion.

Gail Benoit
Gail Benoit
Two useful tags. Click either to see the articles: Toxic to cats | Dangers to cats

As a result I can describe her attitude towards animals as immoral and unethical. She’s the sort of person I detest.

On the other hand we have animal welfare advocate, Sonya Higgins who rescues and helps stray and feral cats.

They met in court room in Dartmouth, USA. Benoit was there on another charge. This time for allegedly selling cats without a veterinary certificate of health. She had also allegedly refused to provide information required by an Inspector or Peace Officer in the performance of his/her duties.

Higgins was sitting directly in front of Benoit (not a good idea). The contretemps kicked off when Higgins provocatively photographed Benoit on her cellphone. Benoit objected (surprised?).

She said:

“I hope you’re not taking photos of me…”

Higgins replied:

“I hope you’re not stealing cats.”

You can feel the hatred between the two. Benoit escalated things when she called over a sheriff. The judge, Justice Flora Buchan, had yet to enter the court room. The sheriff took Higgins to one side and told her to stop taking photos. Fair enough. It is universally forbidden to take photos in court. I guess Higgins felt she could surreptitiously sneak one in.

When Higgins went back to her seat Benoit leant over and threatened her:

“You, you should be taking pictures of yourself. Look at ya. Just look at ya. You better watch yourself when you’re out of here.”

This gave Higgins the opportunity to complain about Benoit to the police. The police had a word with Benoit but decided the threat was not severe enough to warrant a charge.

Later Higgins said:

“It’s not acceptable to threaten people and I’m not going to take it. I don’t accept intimidation…”

In typical court process style, the hearing was adjourned until August 5th. Courts are not the fastest moving organisations. It is not often two people from the opposite ends of the spectrum on animal welfare meet. I guess the result was predicable.

Sources: three website. The main one is this one.

Useful tag. Click to see the articles: Cat behavior

6 thoughts on “Serial pet abuser and trader threatens animal welfare advocate in court”

  1. Ofcourse, Benoit was threatening. She was confronted and, clearly, in the wrong.
    But, to have done so in that setting, should have been very damaging for her.

  2. Wish I had been there in Higgin’s stead because I would have wind up in the pokey because I would have told her (Benoit) to bring it on when we got outside,when it comes to cats I will defend them be them mine or not,I hope someone will put the hurt on her some day!

Leave a Reply to Dee (Florida) Cancel Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Note: sources for news articles are carefully selected but the news is often not independently verified.
Useful links
Anxiety - reduce it
FULL Maine Coon guide - lots of pages
Children and cats - important
Scroll to Top