Speciesism is applied less by the British compared to New Zealanders

A survey carried out by the University of Exeter concerning the difficulties of distinguishing between wildcats and feral cats in order to control feral cat populations, came to the conclusion that speciesism is applied less often in Britain than in New Zealand.

What is speciesism?
What is speciesism? Image by MikeB based on images in the public domain as assessed. Click it for a larger version.
Two useful tags. Click either to see the articles:- Toxic to cats | Dangers to cats

What is speciesism? It is valuing one species of animal above another. The classic situation is killing feral cats to protect birds. Or killing feral cats to protect precious and endangered native species. The ultimate example is rating humans over all animals.

RELATED: 3 definitions of ‘speciesism’ plus a discussion and an infographic

You could also argue that speciesism is applied when supporting domestic cats killing rats. In an absolute sense, rats are sentient beings. They are smart and some people keep rats as pets. But people tend to perceive rats as pests and domestic cats as lovable companions. That is speciesism.

And in Britain people don’t apply that kind of rule or they apply it less often than in New Zealand where they are less sentimental about killing feral cats. The same would apply to Australia. In Australia the feral cat is hated and therefore persecuted it seems to me judging by the news media articles on the topic.

But this is partly because Australians are rowing back from a disastrous period during which native species have been lost for various reasons including human activities such as building new homes and destroying habitat and climate change. The feral cat is blamed. It’s a passing the buck process.

But that’s another story. This study found that New Zealanders are “much less sentimental about pest management to protect native species”. The quote comes from the Science Daily website which reports on the study.

Researchers interviewed those involved in cat conservation in New Zealand and Britain. They found that “public opinion is very much against culling feral cats” in Britain. And that would apply even in the interest of protecting the highly endangered if not extinct Scottish wildcat. In Britain, TNR is practised to control feral cat populations rather than simply culling them.

There is a practical aspect of this because it has been found many times that simply killing feral cats does not solve the feral cat population problem whereas widespread TNR will achieve the goal.

Although I fully understand that in Australia TNR is probably impractical in many places because feral cats have gone into the wild outback where they occupy very large home ranges and are therefore very dispersed.

But avoiding culling feral cats has advantages. If you go around shooting feral cats you might shoot someone’s pet domestic cat because it is very hard to tell the difference between a feral cat and a domestic cat at a distance particularly if it’s a tabby cat. You might even be shooting a wildcat because they are tabby cats. It’s problematic to put it mildly. Shooting a pet is a crime in all countries except places like China where there are no general animal welfare laws.

In New Zealand it is legal to shoot feral cats. They even had a competition in which young kids were given prizes to shoot feral cats which was frowned upon by many people. I wrote about that which you can read by clicking this link if you wish.

In the UK, the killing of feral cats is problematic. It impractical to provide a black and white answer as to whether it is legal to kill feral cats in the UK. I discussed the topic many years ago. If you wish to read that article, please check on this link.

Philosophically speaking, I would argue that the more sophisticated a society is the more likely they are to shun speciesism.

RELATED: The woke movement and speciesism

7 thoughts on “Speciesism is applied less by the British compared to New Zealanders”

  1. Australians and New Zealanders generally do not care about any indigenous people, let alone indigenous feral cats. Sadly, they probably also equate feral cats with stray cats.

    Reply
    • The Chinese are also serious speciesists, thanks to a lot of publicity from lovers of birds, reptiles, etc., and the media. There are a lot of cat haters in China, and they like to kill cats for fun

      Reply
      • ‘Kill cats for fun’. I hate to read that. It indicates a terribe attitude of great cruelty and insensitivity. It also indicates a terrible culture and a poorly developed society. Shame on them.

        Reply
        • Killing cats, especially strays, is considered a good thing in China, where many believe cats are an invasive species because of research in the United States

          Reply
          • Yeh, well the Chinese have, in general, a disfunctional relationship with animals. Far too much animal cruelty in China. Damn it, the country is known for animal cruelty. It is bloody well notorious for it 🤢.

            Reply
            • If Americans could change their research on domestic cats and recognize them as part of the ecological chain of cities and towns, if they did, it might also have political implications for China and give it an edge over China. While the Chinese are clamoring for legislation against cruelty, many Chinese media outlets will release Australian and American studies on stray cats. To push for legislation against abuse

              Reply
            • If Americans could change their research on domestic cats and recognize them as part of the ecological chain of cities and towns, if they did, it might also have political implications in China, giving the West an edge over China. When Chinese people clamor for legislation against cruelty, many Chinese media outlets would release Australian and American studies on stray cats. In opposition to calling for legislation against abuse, so that many people will think that calling for legislation is vexatious, killing cats is a good thing

              Reply

Leave a Comment

follow it link and logo