Categories: Declawing

Statewide declaw ban is government overreach?

Assembleyman Crouch against statewide declaw ban. This is his argument. Screenshot. Text added by PoC.

Michigan state is debating a ban on declawing. If the legislation is passed Michigan would become the second state after New York to ban declawing. During the New York debate State Assemblyman Clifford Crouch speaking inside the NY state legislature said that a ban on declawing across the state is government overreach. As it happens New York State did ban declawing so the majority agreed that banning declawing statewide is acceptable.

Reasons for overreach

However, the idea of ‘government overreach’ is an argument that needs to be addressed. Crouch cites two reasons why he was against the Bill: vets don’t want a ban and ‘people are very susceptible to infections by cat scratches and things like that’.


His two points are failures. The vets are bound to be against a ban because the operation is bread and butter to them. As to people being susceptible to infections by cat scratches this is a feeble argument. It is a balance between the welfare of 2 species of animal: the cat and the human-animal and not doing a brutal partial amputation of ten toes against people being occasionally scratched. You cannot justify the horror of declawing to prevent the occasional scratch which is often caused by careless cat ownership. Also infections from cat scratches are relatively scarce. What I mean is the percentage of scratches that become infected compared to the total number of scratches is very low.

Kids mishandling cats

A study published on the website concluded:

The incidence of patients discharged from hospitals with a diagnosis of cat scratch disease was between 0.77 and 0.86 per 100,000 population per year. Fifty-five percent of the case patients were 18 years of age or younger. Males accounted for 60% of cases. Incidence varied by season; approximately 60% of case patients were discharged in the months September through January. The estimated incidence of disease in ambulatory patients was 9.3 per 100,000 population per year. On the basis of these rates, we estimated the annual health care cost of the disease to be more than $12 million.

The numbers are low. Infections from scratches are not something which can justify declawing. Standard bacterial infections other than from Bartonella henselae are rarely caused by scratches. Also you can see that young males are most often scratched and get cat scratch disease. This points to people mishandling cats. This is about educating young men and boys on how to handle domestic cats. That’s the way to deal with cat scratch fever, not to brutalise the cat with an horrendous operation.

Moral dimension

Crouch completely misses the moral and philosophical dimension of declawing. It is clearly wrong morally because if a person wants to adopt a cat they adopt they whole cat and not a modified version. You don’t buy customised cats like you buy customised cars. That’s not the deal. And philosophically speaking the concept of cat domestication does not include declawing. The deal is that the human takes care of their cat and their cat provides companionship and entertainment. There are no terms and conditions which says that the human has the right to physically, severely injure the cat as a condition of their ‘ownership’ of the cat.

In other words there is no moral right for the human to declaw cats. Legally it is allowed in all states bar New York but this is an aberration in the law because declawing is legalised criminality. That sounds extreme but it it not. If vets did the operation in many countries (35) including the UK they’d end up in the criminal courts on a charge of animal cruelty. That proves the point. America is the odd man out.

Politicians need educating about declawing

It seems to me that Crouch does not know the ins and outs of declawing. He is unaware of the huge number of botched declawing operations for example and the complications that often flow from the operation. The wool has been drawn over his eyes by the vets who are fighting to defend the indefensible. My advise to the politicians voting on declawing bans is to ignore the lobbying of vets. They will lie as they lie to their clients when they understate the negative effects of the operation and misrepresent the severity of the operation. Even the name is a misrepresentation: declawing. This means to remove the claw. It does not. It removes part of the toe from the last knuckle – times ten. It is bloody and bloody painful. It is hell for the cat.


This is Ruth's second podcast from Wisconsin, USA. She provides insights into cat guardianship (aka ownership) in a country which ...
Read More
For quite a while the American state of New Jersey has been debating a ban on declawing cats. It looks ...
Read More
This is another great step in the direction of totally removing cat declawing from America. The movement to stop declawing ...
Read More
The AVMA have carried out their five-yearly review of declawing and decided to toughen their declawing policy by discouraging it ...
Read More
The title says it. The St. Louis Post-Dispatch reports that the Board of Aldermen of the city voted 21-1 for ...
Read More
On their Facebook webpage, The Paw Project have partially published, 2 days ago, the findings of a study which concluded ...
Read More
The complications of declawing are legendary but the many vets (tens of thousands and the majority of American vets) say ...
Read More
It is reported that a bill has been introduced by Sen. Lauren Book of the Florida state legislature to ban ...
Read More
I will tell you why I think that the New York state ban on cat declawing is the single biggest ...
Read More
Cornell broke their promise to Rhoda Horgan to spend her bequest in her will of US$125,000 to fight cat declawing ...
Read More
Please comment here using either Facebook or WordPress (when available).
Michael Broad

Hi, I am 70-years-of-age at 2019. For 14 years before I retired at 57, I worked as a solicitor in general law specialising in family law. Before that I worked in a number of different jobs including professional photography. I have a longstanding girlfriend, Michelle. We like to walk in Richmond Park which is near my home because I love nature and the landscape (as well as cats and all animals).

Leave a Comment

View Comments

  • Mostly boys under 18 because A. they were probably asking for it and 2. boys are filthy, disgusting and irresponsible so likely didn't wash the scratch or apply disinfectant.

    The Assemblyman is a jerk who employed a simpleton's reasoning. No thought given to the fact that it's natures way of telling us we're doing something wrong, we should be sensitive to what cats like or not like and that we should think of ways to address this without mutilating the animal. Be nice, clean the scratch, put out some PSAs to that effect. Screw the industry (vets who want to profit off the mutilations).

    • Well said Albert. Love your passion. Just like me :) I hate, with a vengence, declawing. I find it hard to think of the millions of kittens being injured by this operation. It hurts me.

Recent Posts

China’s Shenzhen bans eating cats and dogs, encouraged by the coronavirus crisis

NEWS/OPINION: Something good has come out of the coronavirus crisis. In fact, I would argue,…

1 hour ago

Is the Singapura cat hypoallergenic?

I am afraid the Singapura cat is not hypoallergenic. This cat is said to be…

2 hours ago

Why are British Shorthair cats so expensive?

As there is nothing to compare the price against except other popular pedigree cats it…

8 hours ago

British laissez-faire attitude towards letting their cat go outside is under scrutiny due to Covid-19

The Brits are well known for letting their domestic cat companions wander around outside as…

9 hours ago

Coronavirus may benefit companion animals and owners by encouraging remote diagnosis

In the USA, and I expect elsewhere to a lesser extent, veterinary telemedicine is being…

14 hours ago

Pictures of cat tapeworm and tapeworm segments

Here is a collage of cat tapeworms and tapeworm segments that I have prepared because…

14 hours ago