Categories: conservation

What do Americans think about the European Union’s statement that they support the right of domestic cats to freedom of movement?

You may have picked up on the claim by a couple of Dutch professors that European Union laws prevent cat owners allowing their cats to go outside except on a leash. The scientists’ argument is that free-roaming outside cats damage wildlife, particularly birds – the old, classic argument that we hear a lot. Incidentally, I don’t understand why birds are given priority over other wild animals.

Larry and Boris. Photo: no idea who took it. Probably one of his advisers at No 10. At the heart of the UK government we have a free-roaming domestic cat, Larry.

As soon as the discussion surfaced I wrote an article saying the professors’ arguments were incorrect. I was proved correct but I wasn’t being particularly clever. I was applying common sense, something the academics in this instance lacked. Or were they the voice of ornithologists? It seems the war of words between cat lovers and bird lovers has entered the highest echelons of European government.

A discussion was started over whether the EU laws (directives and regulations) could be construed to banish domestic cats to the indoors. It was soon reported online that the EU Commission (the EU executive body which formulates law):

“The Commission is a strong defender of free movement rights — including of cats…The commission is not aware of the study in question…The information that we have is that the disturbance and killing of birds and other wild species by cats is not among the main pressures and threats to biodiversity…” – Enrico Brivo, the executive’s environment spokesman.

For cat lovers this is quite a nice statement coming from someone in such an elevated place of influence in the EU. It is a statement which protects the status quo of free-roaming domestic cats rather than protecting wildlife. What do Americans think about it?

SOME MORE ON FREE-ROAMING DOMESTIC CATS..

Outdoor domestic cats generally wander fairly close to home

ABC News San Diego have commented on an Australian survey of outdoor domestic cat wanderings and their conclusion is incorrect ...
Read More

Cat owner writes threatening note to neighbour about his cat eating her cat’s food

This spat between cat owners has its roots in the distinctly British culture of allowing domestic cats to roam freely ...
Read More

Cat owner ear tipped their domestic cat’s left ear to make him acceptable under the law

In America, local laws concerning cat ownership, feral cats, TNR and outside cats vary which can cause confusion and it ...
Read More

Is it legal to let your cat roam freely?

As Internet users ask the question: 'is it legal to let your cat roam freely?' - I feel obliged to ...
Read More

Kenai Council proposes cats be restrained outdoors by ‘a leash, fence or building’

Should it be a city ordinance for cats to be on restrained outdoors in the same manner as dogs with ...
Read More
Please comment here using either Facebook or WordPress (when available).
Michael Broad

Hi, I am 70-years-of-age at 2019. For 14 years before I retired at 57, I worked as a solicitor in general law specialising in family law. Before that I worked in a number of different jobs including professional photography. I have a longstanding girlfriend, Michelle. We like to walk in Richmond Park which is near my home because I love nature and the landscape (as well as cats and all animals).

View Comments

  • Primates [humans] are rampantly out of control. Until we get our own act together, we have no right to complain about animals.

Recent Posts

For indoor cats, energy efficient homes may have a health drawback

Energy efficient homes tend to be built airtight to save energy which may trap polluted air inside risking the health…

1 hour ago

Picture of Tilapia fish skin burn treatment on cat’s flank

WARNING - THE PICTURE MAY DISTURB SOME PEOPLE. I THINK IT IS ACCEPTABLE: This is a cat picture which I…

10 hours ago

Pictures of close friendship between meerkat adopted from zoo and domestic cat

St. Petersburg, Russia: The Daily Mail reports that Ekaterina Kuraeva, 45, adopted a meerkat from Moscow Zoo six years ago…

11 hours ago

BBC viewers criticise the BBC article ‘My boyfriend dumped me but how do I tell my cat?’

On the BBC Newswatch television programme, hosted currently by Samira Ahmed, viewers called in and criticised the BBC Trending news…

20 hours ago

Big cat sighting in Southern Italy is likely to be genuine

This is one of the few possibly genuine big cat sightings in Europe. So often they are domestic cats. There…

1 day ago

A scientific reminder of the obvious: domestic cats are as friendly as toddlers and dogs

I'll cut to the chase as I have mentioned this study before but Michelle Starr of MSN has nicely picked…

1 day ago