If you read up on what appears to be slightly strange feline behaviour you will probably find different answers. They are all speculative because we don’t know for sure why domestic cats sometimes grab a piece of food from a bowl in their jaws and then deposit that food in the area around the food bowl and eat it there. What advantage is there to eating food outside of the bowl?
Because nobody answers the question in a definitive way, I am free to make up my own mind! My initial feeling is that it is not strange at all but natural. It is more natural for a cat to eat off the floor than in a bowl because their behavior is dictated by their ancestral wildcat’s behavioral instincts. There are no food bowls in the wild 😎✔️.
Personal observation
I have watched my cat do this. And I think I have a telling reason why they do it. I provide my cat with high quality wet cat food. I also provide him sometimes with king prawns which he adores.
Sometimes the wet cat food clumps together. It forms quite a large clump. Under these circumstances he tends to take it outside of the bowl and eats it there. He might do the same thing with a big prawn.
Domestic cats have become scavengers!
My distinct impression is that he is taking a large chunk of food from the bowl to protect it. Why should he do this? A domestic cat sees the food in his food bowl as a prey animal carcass. He is scavenging at that time. He is not killing an animal but coming across a dead animal and scavenging.
In his mind there might be other scavengers around. He needs to protect his find. He grabs what he can and then takes it away from the carcass. At least he has something. He can lay claim to a large piece of the found food. And if in the meantime no other predator has taken any more of the carcass he will return and do the same thing again or feed directly from it.
Protecting food
So, my distinct impression is that when cats remove food from their food bowl, they are protecting their food from other predators. This looks ridiculous because the cat is in a home and unless it is a multi-cat home with other cats who want to eat from the same bowl, he does not need to protect his food.
But this is entirely instinctive. Every action that a domestic cat makes is based upon the instincts that he inherited from the North African wildcat. Whenever you assess a domestic cat’s behaviour you always refer back to the wild cat ancestor and how they would behave under certain circumstances.
So that, is the first possible reason that this form of feline behaviour. Below are a couple more options.
Eating from the bowl is irritating
Perhaps the bowl is too narrow and the cat’s whiskers are touching the sides and he doesn’t like it. It’s just irritating. It is sometimes called ‘whisker stress’. Therefore, he removes the food from the bowl and eats at his comfort. This is a very practical reason.
Eating from the bowl is more difficult
Perhaps he’s eating dry cat food. He’s trying to get his jaws around a small pallet at the bottom of the bowl. It’s a bit tricky and therefore he decides to grab some pellets and deposit them outside the bowl where he can eat them more comfortably. This is a similar reason to the one above.
Bowls are unnatural!
Cat food bowls are inherently unnatural to domestic cats because they would normally eat in the open on the ground. Domestic cats only eat from bowls because it is convenient for their owner. Perhaps it is this unnaturalness which drives a cat to sometimes grab the food quickly and deposit it in an area around the bowl before eating it.
Personally, I favour the first reason but I welcome any other viewpoints and comments. All three reasons are probably applicable.
Video example from Reddit
This video may stop working! I don’t control it.
