Cat show judge mistakes ring-tailed lemur for domestic cat!

This is a story from the early days of the cat fancy when things were not quite so sophisticated. At the Crystal Palace cat show of 1900 the ‘Madagascar Cat’ was exhibited in the foreign class. I guess the ‘foreign class’ meant domestic cats from countries other than England. It means something different today: slender cats because cats from hot climates i.e. foreign lands, are more slender.

A show judge, Miss H Cochran, decided that she was looking at a cat when she was actually judging a ring-tailed lemur, a fruit-eating primate. They do look somewhat different to domestic cats 🙂 ! Below is a photograph of a ring-tailed lemur.

Ringtailed lemur

Ringtailed lemur. Image by Bart-ter-Haar from Pixabay

Can tigers mate with lions, leopards and jaguars?
The best source for information of this kind is Sarah Hartwell's messybeast.com. She is quite clear on this. While lions, ...
Read More
Domestic cats can and do mate with many species of wild cat
Yes, domestic cats can and do mate (breed) with wildcats. There is a slight complication in answering the question to ...
Read More
Chausie
Hybrid cats can be divided into three categories, entirely domestic cat hybrids (domestic cat x domestic cat), wild cat hybrids ...
Read More

The mistake was reported in the news media. Miss Cochran defended herself by simply saying: “A lemur is a lemur, but a Madagascar cat is a Madagascar cat”. Yes, I agree but you were judging a primate, an animal in the same order of species as monkeys.

It seems that in those days the attitude to the type of cat that was allowed to compete was much wider as a number of what appears to have been wild cat hybrids or hybrids from cross-species mattings such as a marten and cat were exhibited. This matting is impossible.

Perhaps this lack of fundamental knowledge opened the door to the farcical mistake made by Miss Cochrane. Crystal Palace was the venue for the first cat show in England in 1897. Crystal Palace was an amazing construction; a cast iron and plate glass structure.

My thanks to Sarah Hartwell and her website messybeast.com.


Note: sources for news articles are carefully selected but the news is often not independently verified.

Michael Broad

Hi, I'm a 74-year-old retired solicitor (attorney in the US). Before qualifying I worked in many jobs including professional photography. I love nature, cats and all animals. I am concerned about their welfare. If you want to read more click here.

You may also like...

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *