Irish Vegan Animal Lover and Graduate Secretly Brutalised Flatmate’s Cat

A 24-year-old Northern Irishman, Declan Garrity, was working for Barclay’s Bank in New York on a work visa. He had a good job and lived in a stimulating place to work with prospects of career advancement. Garrity is an honours graduate from a good university: Queens University in Belfast. He had it all. He professed to be a vegan on Facebook and a person concerned with the welfare of farm livestock. In short, he appeared to be an animal lover.

Garrity (in court?)
Until September 7th I will give 10 cents to an animal charity for every comment written by visitors. It is a way visitors can contribute to animal welfare without much effort and no financial cost. Please comment. It helps this website too which at heart is about cat welfare.

He shared an Upper East Side apartment with a cat owner and her cat, Lucy. Soon after moving in Lucy’s owner (we don’t know her name) became gravely concerned about Lucy’s appearance and behaviour. Lucy began hiding and lost her appetite. She licked her paw indicating an injury. On Jan 25th 2016 Garrity told her “an iron had fell on the cat”. As it happened Lucy’s pelvis was broken. This may not have been apparent until later.


Around a month later on Feb 20th Lucy’s owner arrived home from work to the sight of Lucy’s rear paw pointing in the wrong direction. There was cat hair and blood on towels in the bathroom.

It transpired that Lucy had been systematically and viscously abused and was suffering from a series of injuries including a broken leg, teeth, ribs and claws and burns.

Garrity was interviewed by the police. He told them that he was alone with Lucy during the previous night. He was arrested and charged with animal torture and cruelty and released on $5,000 bail with an order that he stay away from the apartment. He was allowed to return to the apartment supervised by the police to pick up his belongings.

He was soon in contempt of this court order as he returned to the apartment unsupervised and was therefore arrested again and released on bail of $1,000.

Clearly Garrity has a disregard for the law and a viscous streak (on the basis that the charges are proved to be true in a criminal court which seems very likely).

Barclays Bank said euphemistically:

“Mr.Garrity is no longer with Barclays.”

Translation: he was sacked. It would seem – and I am speculating – the second arrest and charge of contempt of court was the last straw for Barclays and there was no need to await the outcome of the animal cruelty charges.

For me the interesting aspect of this case is that Garrity does not look like your typical cat abuser and torturer. He is educated and had an excellent job and a future. We’d have to speculate some more and say that he has a problem. He has an anger and personality problem and is a danger to people, I suspect.

The kind of abuse he allegedly dished out to Lucy is very grave. A grand jury had decided to indict him on eight felony charges concerning the cat abuse and his contempt of court.

As for Lucy she has been under veterinary care since late February. Her broken leg is due to be operated on this week. Lucy’s owner had her home for two days only, otherwise she full-time in the care of medical staff. The funding for this appears to have come from an online crowd-funding campaign which has raised an astonishing $11,700 from 425 donators. It is probably higher than this already. There is a lot of sympathy amongst the public and rightly so.

Is there a moral to this story? Yes; be very wary of letting a person share an apartment with you and your cat unless you know him/her extremely well. You never can tell. Animal abusers are good liars you know.

Source: CNBC

4 thoughts on “Irish Vegan Animal Lover and Graduate Secretly Brutalised Flatmate’s Cat”

  1. As far as animal abuse stories, this one has almost as good of an ending as one could hope for. Justice was served, the victim survived and will have the love and support she truly deserves, and people have shown compassion and generosity towards Lucy the cat. Thanks for sharing this story — it’s one of the few abuse stories that won’t keep me tossing and turning at night.

    So many abuse stories have much worse endings, and what’s extremely hard for me is I feel powerless to do anything that might make the situation better. In the case of Lucy, I feel the online crowd-funding campaign is a wonderful way to let people deal with their anger and their sense of powerlessness. Last night I was reading an awful account of two cats that were brutally killed by a man that broke into a Phoenix pet boarding facility. I so wanted to do something — anything — to help catch the killer and to help the poor owner of the two cats. Unfortunately, there didn’t seem to be much a person could do but voice their frustration in in article posts.

    • You make a great point Rena about the crowd funding campaign allowing people to do something. To express their feelings and in a positive way. I want this man to be severely punished but it is nice to help to create a good ending (which seems likely to happen). Poor Lucy. It must have been terrifying for her.

    Poor Lucy suffered an unending assault of injurious pain and unimaginable suffering.
    I have the belief that anyone who is capable of this type of cruelty, is capable of hurting anyone. Even ending their lives at a moment of rage. This man is a neurotic psychopath, and should be in a federal penitentiary.
    Eva says & you’re free to quote me on this one.

  3. I want this POS Irish National deported back to Belfast,he now has no employment so there is nothing keeping him here other than waiting for the trial and I also want him to compensate Lucy’s owner for undue duress and emotional pain!


Leave a Comment

follow it link and logo