Is it right that veterinarians are cheaper than doctors?

I was reading an article by Siamic on my website entitled: Benefits of Dental Radiography for Relieving Pain in Cats. There is a story about a cat, Hershey, who received cheap dental work which left him in certain pain in my view. I was shocked at the poor standard of care.

Veterinarians are cheaper than doctors. Is this right?

It made me think about the cost of veterinary work compared to that of doctors. Quick research told me that American vets charge $10 to $15 for a simple tooth extraction. Even ‘elevated extractions’ cost a measly $30 (I presume you add anesthetic costs, however). Dentists for people charge $150-$650 for a surgical extraction using anaesthesia. Although it appears that comparisons are difficult. Another example from the UK may help: a female dog spaying may seem pricey at £300, but the standard cost of a human hysterectomy is around £5,000 when done by a private human surgeon which puts veterinary fees into perspective.

Without overanalysing it, removing a tooth from a person costs a lot more than from a cat but cat owners often think that vets are too expensive. And dentists are cheaper than doctors. Other surgeries are considerably more expensive for humans compared to animals.

There can only be one reason why: the costs to veterinarians of veterinary work is lower than for doctor’s. That means less or cheaper equipment, lower salaries, less overheads at the clinic etc..Salaries are fixed by the market. Vets will pay themselves what the market allows i.e. what they can get away with. The same goes for doctors but in the UK they are normally employed by the NHS which means they are not private enterprises charging what they can. And the NHS hides the cost because it is free at the point of delivery.

If the overheads are lower for vets compared to doctors it means that the standards are likely to be lower. So why are the standards lower for cats than for humans? I’d like anyone who reads this to think about that and work it out for themselves.

But the point I am making is that in a better world vets should charge the same as doctors and the standard of care should be the same while the doctors and vets should not prioritise making money but providing the best quality care. The money will come.

How many cats are left in permanent discomfort at best or pain at worst after dental surgery (or any other surgery including declawing) at the vets because of low standards of treatment? They’ll be more than you care to think about. The big weakness in the chain of events in treating animals is that they can’t tell us if they are in pain. This opens the door to poor treatments. Unscrupulous vets drive a horse and cart through it.

Reddit.com tells me that the way health insurance is set up in the USA, it can give the impression that vets are more expensive than doctors. The reverse is true.

What do you think?

SOME ARTICLES ON DENTAL CARE IN CATS:

Top three cat health insurance claims

This page discusses the top three cat health insurance claims in America as per five pet insurance companies (2018). Trupanion ...
Read More

Cat was brained damaged during teeth cleaning

Guilt-ridden cat owner’s British Shorthair brain damaged during dental cleaning

Introduction I have written about this before. There is a risk when a domestic cat is taken to the veterinarian ...
Read More

Loki, the celebrity Sphynx cat, died soon after teeth cleaning

As a reminder that veterinary dental cleaning is risky, this celebrity cat, Loki, who had the grumpiest facial expression of ...
Read More

Does dry cat food clean teeth?

No, dry cat food does not clean a cat's teeth despite what the pet food manufacturers claim. When humans eat ...
Read More

We need to formulate a method to prevent poor feline oral health

Nowhere near enough is being done to keep our cats' teeth clean and their gums healthy. Dental calculus is by ...
Read More

Feral cat’s veterinary bill is $7583.57 and rising

Hoppy was a 'feral' cat. The description of 'feral' is in inverted commas because I am not sure he was ...
Read More

Cat Asks For Breakfast

Just took this photo about 40 minutes ago. It's Charlie asking, nay demanding, breakfast and he is not altogether happy ...
Read More

Getting Cats Accustomed to Various Treatments

I have always adopted adult cats. Maybe next time, I'll be different. And if and when I do adopt a ...
Read More

Please comment here using either Facebook or WordPress (when available).

You make some awesome points Michael, it is a sad world we live in where veterinarians can take advantage of people. Choosing a veterinarian is really hard for a rescue or even an individual which is another post I am making soon. I paid $200 for the full mouth dental of 28 teeth which was done wrong – and had a gut feeling it was too good to be true or too cheap to be done right. So many roots left behind. My primary was going to charge $800 so of course I was naive and took
The cheaper route. These cheaper vets usually cut corners like forgoing pain medications, trading out safer anesthesia for more risky but cheaper anesthetic and utilizing cheap and ineffective antibiotics. Many times the vet is doing surgery and monitoring anesthesia at the same time which is very frowned upon. A dental done right should include a good antibiotic like clindamycin with any tooth extraction, onsior or another pain medication for 2 to 3 days and a dental radiograph before and after the procedure. Then cleaning the rest of the teeth and applying a dental sealant. Unfortunately that often does not happen at cheap vets. For $800 for a full mouth removal at a good vet you will get peace of mind – you get the correct antibiotics, safer anesthetic, pain meds, a tech that will actually monitor the anesthesia while the vet concentrates on surgery. Anyone that has thought twice about why some vets charge less – should always follow up on those feelings by asking questions. There is always a reason why – sometimes that reason is shortcuts to increase profit margins. I have always – always had it bite me when I went the cheap route. Never again will I try to save money. Being on a budget is hard – but I glean guarantee you will spend more by tying to spend less. One other situation I had was a vet who wanted to prescribe a medication for 2x the cost, was last used 10 years ago and was dangerous to a cat’s liver. A cheaper and more effective alternative was readily available for ringworm. They recommend ketoconazole, I used itrafungol. I just cannot blindly trust every vet anymore.

Reply ↓

Comments

Is it right that veterinarians are cheaper than doctors? — 1 Comment

Siamic on April 11, 2020 at 11:40 am said:
You make some awesome points Michael, it is a sad world we live in where veterinarians can take advantage of people. Choosing a veterinarian is really hard for a rescue or even an individual which is another post I am making soon. I paid $200 for the full mouth dental of 28 teeth which was done wrong – and had a gut feeling it was too good to be true or too cheap to be done right. So many roots left behind. My primary was going to charge $800 so of course I was naive and took
The cheaper route. These cheaper vets usually cut corners like forgoing pain medications, trading out safer anesthesia for more risky but cheaper anesthetic and utilizing cheap and ineffective antibiotics. Many times the vet is doing surgery and monitoring anesthesia at the same time which is very frowned upon. A dental done right should include a good antibiotic like clindamycin with any tooth extraction, onsior or another pain medication for 2 to 3 days and a dental radiograph before and after the procedure. Then cleaning the rest of the teeth and applying a dental sealant. Unfortunately that often does not happen at cheap vets. For $800 for a full mouth removal at a good vet you will get peace of mind – you get the correct antibiotics, safer anesthetic, pain meds, a tech that will actually monitor the anesthesia while the vet concentrates on surgery. Anyone that has thought twice about why some vets charge less – should always follow up on those feelings by asking questions. There is always a reason why – sometimes that reason is shortcuts to increase profit margins. I have always – always had it bite me when I went the cheap route. Never again will I try to save money. Being on a budget is hard – but I glean guarantee you will spend more by tying to spend less. One other situation I had was a vet who wanted to prescribe a medication for 2x the cost, was last used 10 years ago and was dangerous to a cat’s liver. A cheaper and more effective alternative was readily available for ringworm. They recommend ketoconazole, I used itrafungol. I just cannot blindly trust every vet anymore.
Reply ↓