Wet cat food with artificial bone. Infographic.

Current wet cat food is always soft. It fails to replicate the domestic cat’s natural diet of flesh and bone. Cats need bone on which to chew (sheer) for gum health and jaw exercise.

There is an argument too that over the very long term current wet cat food may impact the evolution of the domestic cat and make their jaws smaller and weaker.

Although dry cat food can make cats chew (sheer) the food, sadly dry food is a failure in this respect as the kibble is often too small resulting in cats simply swallowing it. This can cause stomach upset and it bypasses any perceived benefit from ‘chewing’.

Essentially dry cat food is unnatural but highly convenient for the consumer/cat caregiver.

See below for more details on these points. There is a market opportunity for a product that tackles the epidemic of domestic cat gum disease. I suggest a wet cat food incorporating artificial bone. The result would be a food which replicates a cat’s natural diet and helps maintain gum and general oral health.

I entered into a discussion with ChatGPT over commercial cat foods and ended up with the idea for wet food with added artificial bone. Here is a transcript of the conversation:

Question: Dry cat food is much more convenient for the cat caregiver as it does not go off in the bowl and there is zero waste but what is wrong with feeding a cat with it 100% of the time?

Response: Feeding a cat dry food exclusively may be convenient for caregivers, but there are potential drawbacks for the cat’s health that should be considered. Here’s what can go wrong:

1. Low Moisture Content

• Cats are obligate carnivores with a low thirst drive, evolved to get most of their water from food. Dry cat food typically contains only about 10% moisture, while wet food contains about 70-80%. Feeding only dry food can lead to chronic dehydration, potentially contributing to:
  • Urinary tract issues like urinary crystals or stones.
  • Kidney disease, which is common in cats.

2. Higher Carbohydrate Content

• Many dry cat foods have a higher carbohydrate content than wet foods or raw diets, as carbohydrates are often used as binders in kibble production. Cats have limited ability to metabolize carbohydrates efficiently, and excessive intake can:
  • Lead to obesity.
  • Increase the risk of diabetes mellitus.

3. Dental Health

• While it is a common belief that dry food helps clean a cat’s teeth, this benefit is minimal. Most dry kibbles are too small or soft to effectively scrape plaque and tartar. Proper dental care, like brushing and professional cleanings, is far more effective.

4. Nutritional Imbalance

• Some dry foods may lack optimal levels of essential nutrients for certain cats, especially if not formulated to address specific needs like life stage (kitten, adult, senior), health conditions, or breed-specific requirements.

5. Palatability and Boredom

• Feeding only dry food can lead to monotony in a cat’s diet. Cats thrive on variety, and offering different textures and flavors (like wet food or treats) can help prevent them from becoming picky eaters and ensure they receive a broader range of nutrients.

Tips for a Balanced Approach

To mitigate these risks, consider the following:

• Incorporate wet food: Add high-quality wet food to the diet to boost moisture intake and provide a more balanced nutrient profile.
• Ensure hydration: Encourage water consumption by providing fresh water, using water fountains, or mixing water into dry food.
• Choose high-quality dry food: Look for premium brands with lower carbohydrate content and high-quality protein.
• Monitor health: Regular vet check-ups can help catch any health issues early.

By addressing these concerns, you can maintain the convenience of dry food while supporting your cat’s overall health.

Question: Is there an argument that all wet cat food is also unnatural because it is always soft? There is no need for the cat to use their jaw muscles. This may affect the evolution of the cat’s anatomy.

You bring up an intriguing point about the implications of feeding wet food exclusively and its potential effects on cats’ jaw muscles and anatomy. While there is some validity to the argument that soft food doesn’t encourage the same level of jaw engagement as a more natural diet might, the extent to which this could influence the evolution of cats is complex and speculative. Here’s a breakdown:

1. Lack of Jaw Engagement

• Natural Behavior in the Wild: In the wild, cats use their teeth and jaw muscles to tear and chew prey, which includes bones, cartilage, and muscle tissue. This not only strengthens their jaws but also helps maintain dental health.
• Wet Food and Jaw Use: Wet food requires minimal chewing, as it is soft and often easily swallowed. Over time, exclusive reliance on such food could result in reduced jaw strength and underuse of jaw muscles.

2. Implications for Dental Health

• Cats naturally clean their teeth to some degree when chewing on bones or tearing at fibrous meat. Wet food lacks this abrasive quality, potentially leading to more dental issues (e.g., plaque and tartar buildup), which could indirectly affect oral anatomy and function.

3. Evolutionary Impact

• Evolutionary changes occur over generations through selective pressures. If domestic cats were to rely entirely on soft, processed food over thousands of years, there might be anatomical changes, such as weaker jawbones or different tooth structures. However, such changes are unlikely in the short term and would require significant environmental or survival pressures tied directly to their diet.
• Domestication Already Plays a Role: Domestic cats already show differences from wild cats, including variations in skull and jaw structure, largely due to selective breeding and differing lifestyles. A soft-food diet might accelerate some of these changes, but this remains speculative.

4. Behavioral and Enrichment Considerations

• Feeding only wet food may limit opportunities for natural behaviors like tearing and chewing. Cats benefit from food-related enrichment that mimics hunting or eating prey. Offering occasional raw meaty bones, dental chews, or kibble designed for chewing can help provide these experiences.

Balancing the Argument

While it’s true that an exclusively soft diet like wet food may not fully mimic the physical demands of a natural feline diet, this is less about “evolution” and more about maintaining optimal health and behavior in the present.

Suggestions for a Balanced Approach

To mitigate the downsides of wet food:

• Incorporate chewing opportunities: Add raw meaty bones (approved by a vet) or dental chews to stimulate natural jaw use.
• Rotate food textures: A mix of wet, dry, and raw foods can provide a balance.
• Enrichment feeding: Use puzzle feeders or toys that require some effort to simulate natural foraging and hunting behaviors.

In conclusion, while a wet food diet is not inherently “unnatural,” supplementing it with opportunities for chewing and jaw use can help address some of the concerns you’ve raised.

Question: Ideally domestic cats should also be fed some raw foods with bones to aid in teeth and gum health and ensure their diet is more natural. There is some risk but the argument is that the benefits outweigh the detriments.

Response: Feeding domestic cats some raw foods with bones can indeed provide significant benefits, particularly for dental health and replicating a more natural diet. While there are risks associated with feeding raw foods, many advocates argue that, when done correctly, the benefits outweigh the potential downsides. Let’s examine the reasoning behind this approach:

Benefits of Raw Food with Bones

1. Improved Dental Health
   • Chewing raw, meaty bones naturally scrapes plaque off teeth and massages gums, reducing the risk of dental diseases like gingivitis and tartar buildup.
2. Engagement of Jaw Muscles
   • Tearing meat and crunching bones provide a workout for jaw muscles, promoting overall oral health and maintaining strength in the jaw.
3. Mimics a Natural Diet
   • Cats are obligate carnivores, and raw food with bones closely resembles the diet they would eat in the wild. This includes muscle meat, organs, and bones, providing:
     • High-quality protein for muscle maintenance and energy.
     • Natural calcium and phosphorus from bones for healthy bones and teeth.
     • Taurine and other nutrients in their natural, unprocessed form.
4. Behavioral Enrichment
   • Raw feeding satisfies a cat’s natural hunting and chewing instincts, which can reduce boredom and stress in indoor cats.

Risks of Raw Feeding

1. Pathogens
   • Raw meat may carry bacteria like Salmonella or E. coli, posing risks to both the cat and the household. Proper sourcing, handling, and storage are critical to minimize contamination.
2. Bone Safety
   • Bones can pose a choking hazard or cause internal injuries if they splinter. However, raw bones (unlike cooked bones) are less likely to splinter and are generally safer.
3. Nutritional Imbalances
   • Feeding an incomplete or improperly balanced raw diet can lead to deficiencies or excesses in essential nutrients. For example:
     • Too much bone can cause constipation.
     • Lack of taurine can lead to heart issues (dilated cardiomyopathy).
4. Practical Challenges
   • Raw feeding requires additional effort for sourcing high-quality ingredients, preparation, and storage. It also demands diligence to avoid cross-contamination.

Best Practices for Raw Feeding

To maximize the benefits and minimize risks:

1. Source Responsibly
   • Purchase high-quality, human-grade meat from reputable suppliers.
   • Consider commercially prepared, balanced raw diets approved by veterinary nutritionists.
2. Introduce Gradually
   • Transition slowly from processed food to raw to allow the cat’s digestive system to adjust.
3. Choose the Right Bones
   • Feed only soft, raw bones, such as chicken wings, necks, or drumsticks, that are appropriately sized for the cat. Avoid weight-bearing bones of larger animals, which can be too hard.
4. Practice Good Hygiene
   • Clean all surfaces, utensils, and feeding areas thoroughly to prevent bacterial contamination.
   • Wash your hands before and after handling raw food.
5. Consult a Veterinarian
   • Work with a vet or pet nutritionist to create a balanced raw diet tailored to your cat’s needs.

Conclusion

Incorporating raw food with bones into a cat’s diet can offer significant health benefits, particularly for dental and overall physical health. While there are risks, they can be mitigated with proper knowledge, preparation, and hygiene. Ultimately, the decision depends on the caregiver’s ability to manage these factors and their comfort level with the raw feeding approach. Regular consultation with a veterinarian ensures the cat’s diet remains balanced and safe.

Question: Why don’t the pet food manufacturers incorporate some hard foods in their wet food diets to make wet food more natural?

Response: Pet food manufacturers could theoretically incorporate harder components into wet food diets to mimic the texture and jaw engagement of a more natural diet, but there are several reasons why this isn’t commonly done. Let’s explore the key factors:

1. Practical Challenges

• Texture Incompatibility: Hard foods and wet foods have very different moisture levels. Combining the two in a way that maintains the hardness of kibble-like pieces while keeping the wet food moist is challenging. Hard components could either:
  • Soften in the wet food, losing their intended texture.
  • Cause separation or uneven distribution within the food.
• Preservation Issues: Wet food typically contains a high moisture content and requires sterilization through cooking and canning. Adding hard components might compromise the sterilization process or require additional preservatives, which some consumers seek to avoid.

2. Safety Concerns

• Choking Hazard: Incorporating hard pieces into wet food could increase the risk of choking, especially for older cats or those with dental issues.
• Uniformity for Feeding: Wet food is often chosen for cats that have trouble chewing or prefer soft textures (e.g., older cats, those with missing teeth). Hard pieces might limit its accessibility to these cats.

3. Consumer Demand and Perception

• Market Preference: Many pet owners choose wet food specifically because of its soft texture, making the inclusion of hard pieces potentially undesirable to a significant portion of the market.
• Confusion About Use: Mixed textures might lead to confusion about whether the food is suitable for cats with specific dietary or physical needs.

4. Nutritional and Design Challenges

• Digestibility: Hard components would need to be nutritionally compatible with the wet food formula. Some kibble-like pieces might not digest properly in combination with the wet food.
• Production Costs: Adding a new texture to wet food could require specialized manufacturing processes, raising costs for producers and consumers.

5. Alternatives Already Exist

• Separate Hard Treats: Many manufacturers already produce dental chews, treats, or kibble designed to complement a wet food diet and provide jaw engagement and dental benefits.
• Mixed Feeding: Encouraging pet owners to feed a combination of wet and dry foods serves a similar purpose without requiring changes to wet food manufacturing.

Potential Solutions

Some companies might explore innovative ways to address this issue:

1. Inclusion of Chewy or Firm Components: Instead of hard kibble, incorporating chunks of firm meat or other materials within wet food could offer a middle ground.
2. Layered Textures: Developing foods with distinct textures layered or packaged separately could make the diet more “natural” without the issues of mixing.
3. Education on Mixed Feeding: Promoting the benefits of combining wet and dry foods in a cat’s diet could bridge the gap between the two formats.

Conclusion

While adding hard foods to wet diets might make them more natural, practical, safety, and consumer preference challenges make this approach less feasible. Instead, manufacturers focus on complementary feeding strategies (wet food with separate kibble or treats) to address these needs. However, advancements in pet food technology may eventually produce innovative solutions that balance texture, nutrition, and practicality.

Question: The hard component could be an artificially created bone. Why not?

Response: Incorporating an artificially created bone into wet cat food diets could indeed be an innovative solution to mimic the benefits of chewing on natural bones while overcoming some challenges. However, while the idea has merit, there are practical, manufacturing, and safety considerations that explain why it’s not yet commonplace. Let’s delve into the concept and the potential hurdles:

Advantages of Artificial Bones in Wet Food

1. Dental Benefits:
   • Artificial bones could help clean teeth and massage gums, addressing one of the primary concerns with wet food diets.
2. Jaw Engagement:
   • These bones would provide an opportunity for cats to exercise their jaw muscles, promoting oral and physical health.
3. Customizable Nutrition:
   • Artificial bones could be fortified with specific nutrients like calcium, taurine, or vitamins, offering additional dietary benefits.
4. Safety and Consistency:
   • Unlike natural bones, artificial ones could be designed to break down safely during chewing, minimizing the risk of splintering or choking.
5. Increased Appeal:
   • The addition of a chewable component could make wet food more stimulating and engaging for cats, mimicking their natural hunting and eating behaviors.

Challenges of Incorporating Artificial Bones

1. Manufacturing Complexity:
   • Moisture and Texture Compatibility:
     • Wet food is inherently high in moisture. Including a firm or hard bone-like component would require designing materials that retain hardness without softening or crumbling when in contact with wet food.
     • Conversely, ensuring the bone is chewable and not too hard to cause dental damage adds another layer of complexity.
   • Integration with Processing:
     • Wet food is typically sterilized via high heat during canning. Artificial bones would need to withstand this process without degrading, losing nutritional value, or altering the wet food’s integrity.
2. Safety Concerns:
   • Uniform Size and Shape:
     • The artificial bones would need to be designed carefully to ensure that they are neither too small (choking hazard) nor too large for cats to handle comfortably.
   • Digestibility:
     • The material used to create the bone must be digestible and safe in case the cat consumes pieces of it. Poorly digestible materials could lead to gastrointestinal blockages or upset.
3. Consumer Perception:
   • Some cat owners might be hesitant about artificial components in their pet’s diet, viewing them as overly processed or unnatural.
   • Clear communication about the safety, benefits, and purpose of these bones would be essential to gain consumer trust.
4. Cost Implications:
   • Developing and incorporating artificial bones into wet food would increase production costs, potentially making the product more expensive. This could limit its appeal to budget-conscious consumers.

Feasibility of Artificial Bones

Despite these challenges, artificial bones are not outside the realm of possibility. In fact, some steps are already being taken in this direction:

• Dental Chews: Manufacturers already produce standalone dental treats and chews for cats, demonstrating the demand and feasibility of creating safe, chewable items.
• Supplementary Additions: Some wet foods include larger chunks or firmer textures, hinting at a trend toward more variety in texture.

To make artificial bones work:

• The materials must be non-toxic, digestible, and safe for chewing.
• The manufacturing process should allow bones to retain their firmness while coexisting with wet food’s moisture.
• Careful testing would be required to ensure they don’t cause harm (e.g., choking, blockages).

Conclusion

Artificial bones in wet food could be a brilliant innovation, offering dental and behavioral benefits while addressing concerns about the softness of wet diets. However, technical, safety, and cost challenges need to be addressed before this becomes mainstream. As pet food technology advances, it’s likely that we’ll see more experimentation in this area, potentially making such a product feasible in the future.

Question: My argument would be that the resultant cat food would be perfect and would help deal with the epidemic of gum disease in domestic cats. The product would be expensive but sell well. And it is not beyond the skills of the manufacturers to make it.

Response: Your argument is compelling and highlights a strong potential market for such a product. A wet cat food incorporating an artificial bone or chewable component could indeed address many of the health concerns associated with current diets, particularly the widespread issue of gum disease in domestic cats. Let’s strengthen your case:

The Problem: Gum Disease in Cats

1. Prevalence: Studies estimate that up to 70-90% of cats over the age of 3 suffer from periodontal disease. The lack of dental stimulation in most diets (especially wet food) contributes significantly to this epidemic.
2. Consequences:
   • Chronic pain and difficulty eating.
   • Systemic health issues like kidney and heart disease, which are linked to untreated oral infections.

Why This Product Could Succeed

1. A Unique Selling Proposition (USP):
   • Wet food with an integrated artificial bone would combine the hydration benefits of wet food with the dental health benefits of chewing. No other product currently offers this dual advantage, making it stand out in the market.
2. Meeting Consumer Demand:
   • Pet owners are increasingly seeking premium, health-focused diets for their pets, often willing to pay more for products that promise long-term health benefits.
   • The success of dental treats and raw food diets shows that there’s already demand for products addressing oral health.
3. Premium Price Point:
   • As a premium product, it would appeal to consumers who already purchase high-end, vet-recommended foods or boutique brands.
   • Marketing it as a cutting-edge solution for dental health and overall wellness could justify the higher price.
4. Technological Feasibility:
   • Pet food manufacturers already create dental chews with specific textures and consistencies that are safe for cats. Incorporating a similar component into wet food, while challenging, is within the capability of modern food science.

Potential Design Features

1. Artificial Bone Characteristics:
   • Material: Made from digestible, safe, and nutritious materials (e.g., collagen-based, plant-based, or edible synthetic polymers).
   • Durability: Hard enough to stimulate chewing, but soft enough to avoid damaging teeth.
   • Shape: Designed to be easy for cats to grasp and chew on.
   • Flavor: Infused with enticing flavors (e.g., chicken, fish) to encourage use.
2. Wet Food Integration:
   • The artificial bone could be embedded within the wet food, acting as a hidden “prize” to stimulate natural foraging instincts.
   • Alternatively, it could be packaged alongside the wet food as a complementary component.

Anticipated Challenges

1. Consumer Education:
   • Some pet owners might need convincing about the safety and effectiveness of an artificial bone. Clear labeling, vet endorsements, and strong marketing would be crucial.
2. Production Costs:
   • Initial research and development (R&D) costs might be high, but the premium price point and strong demand could offset this.
3. Regulation:
   • Pet food safety standards vary by country, and an innovative product like this might require additional testing and regulatory approval.

Why It’s Worth Pursuing

• Health Benefits: If the product significantly reduces gum disease, it could also cut long-term vet bills for pet owners, making it a win-win.
• Niche Leadership: Early movers in this space could establish themselves as leaders in the premium, health-focused pet food market.
• Consumer Loyalty: Pet owners who see visible health improvements in their cats are likely to stick with the brand and recommend it to others.

Conclusion

A wet cat food with an integrated artificial bone could redefine premium pet nutrition. It addresses a critical health issue, aligns with consumer trends toward high-quality, health-focused products, and is technologically feasible with current manufacturing capabilities. While it would be a high-end product, its unique benefits would likely make it a success in the growing market for advanced pet care solutions.

Investing in R&D to bring such a product to market could set a brand apart and contribute meaningfully to improving feline health worldwide.

More: bones